Showing posts with label UN TW-USA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UN TW-USA. Show all posts

Friday, December 7, 2007

Is the US a Crying Wolf on Taiwan Referendum?

In November 2003, Taiwan’s Legislative Yuan adopted the Referendum Law and rejected the Executive Yuan from initiating a consultative referendum on three major issues: the downsizing of the number of Legislators, the construction of the fourth nuclear power plant, and the World Health Organization membership. Immediately after the passage of this legislation, President Chen Shui-bian decided to hold the defensive referendum based on Article 17 of the Referendum Law. Ten days later in the White House, President Bush condemned Chen’s action by stating that the US opposed the actions. These remarks created domestic fuss and stirred already tension-prone cross-Strait relations.

Some American scholars of China Studies believed that President Bush was right in employing preventive diplomacy to preclude President Chen from crossing the brink in the later design of questions in the defensive referendum. However, some circles in Taiwan together with some members in the US Congress argued that the US overreacted to Taiwan’s first-ever defensive referendum. In 2004, only 45% of the voters cast their votes on whether Taiwan should increase its missile equipment and conduct negotiations with the PRC. The turnout rate was 5% short of being considered a valid referendum. The vote has never been interpreted as a vote on Taiwan independence. Unfortunately, US Pentagon’s press release misperceived 2008 referendum on Taiwan’s membership in the United Nations as a referendum on Taiwan independence. Only after Taipei’s protest did the Pentagon amend the coverage on the website.

It was not Beijing’s coercive actions that prevented voters from casting the vote on defensive referendum; it was partisan politics which sabotaged the first nation-wide referendum. For example, the Patriot III missiles package was obstructed by the KMT simply because it was legally bound by the referendum outcome in March 2004. Even after three years of blockage, the Kuomintang (KMT) continued to boycott the purchase of Patriot III missiles and only agreed to upgrade the existing PAC-2 in June 2007.

The DPP and the KMT have antagonized each other in almost every public policy. Only on a rare occasion would these two political parties coincide with each other, such as the United Nations (UN) issue, simply with an aim of gaining support from the voters. The UN referendum issue in Taiwan is not about the name of Taiwan, but the frustration in its inability to participate in the UN or other international organizations. This angst garners support within the island regardless of their backgrounds and rally together to appeal for international recognition. It is absurd to prohibit the people of Taiwan to use the very name that foreigners recognize them as.
There are many countries which are known not for its official title. For example, one would call Greece rather than Hellenic Republic and call Switzerland rather than Swiss Confederation. Among the public opinion polls conducted in Taiwan, more than 70% of the people agreed to use the name, Taiwan, to apply for UN membership. The Bush administration should have a second thought before responding to Taiwan’s moves.

The Bush administration has every right to express its concerns about the possible ramifications of Taiwan’s UN referendum. However, Washington should not dictate what actions Taipei should or could adopt. Taiwan has long regarded the US as the friendliest country; Taiwan practice the US democratic ways in daily operations of government, but Taiwan has been repeatedly stabbed behind the back by the US. On October 25, 2004, US Secretary of State Colin Powell stated that Taiwan could not enjoy sovereignty as a nation. Then, Dennis Wilder of National Security Council stated in August 2007 that neither Taiwan nor the ROC is a sovereign state, despite knowing the fact that Taiwan still enjoys diplomatic ties with 24 countries. What worsens the situation is that Deputy Secretary of State, John Negroponte, aligned with Beijing’s stance, and prematurely argued that the UN referendum in Taiwan is a critical step toward Taiwan independence. Some of these statements are a repeat of Secretary Powell’s misspoken episode in October 2004, in which he later clarified that the US policy is based on peaceful resolution of cross-Strait disputes instead of peaceful reunification of Taiwan and China.

While the PRC is nervous about Taiwanese referendum, it is Taipei’s staunch supporter, the US, who exerted pressure on Taipei’s move to conduct the referendum. This attitude might contradict America’s longstanding endorsement of the universality of human rights. Nevertheless, one might argue Washington adheres to its national interest. Taiwan is not expecting the US to wholeheartedly support the island in every domestic move in deepening its democratic foundation. No president in Taiwan is able to dictate the future without the approval of people on Taiwan. President Chen was not popular in many ways but he deserves high regards in placing the UN issue in front of voters on the same day of presidential election.

The outcome of Taiwan’s presidential election is far from predictable, but the KMT will tell its supporter not to cast votes on UN referendum under the name of Taiwan, which it interprets as a referendum towards independence. The KMT has its own version of the UN referendum but people know that it is also difficult to return to the UN under the name of ROC let alone in the capacity of a new membership. If there is a split vote on these two UN referendum version and presidential candidates, the most likely outcome is that neither will pass. Even before the process of UN referendum is finalized by the Central Election Commission, the US government officials such as Deputy Assistant Secretary of State, Thomas Christensen, and AIT Taipei director, Stephen Young, have repeatedly appealed to Taiwanese voters that it is in Taiwan’s interest to prevent the referendum from taking place in the first place and once it is put on the ballot then vote against it.

The Bush administration is punishing President Chen Shui-bian through various channels. For instance, Washington blocked an early approval of the F16 sales to Taiwan even though defense appropriations were approved by the Legislative Yuan in June 2007. Although the Bush administration announced the sales of surface-to-surface Standard Block-III missiles and upgraded equipments of Patriot II surface-to-air missiles to Taiwan, these two sales were approved long before the UN referendum episode.

The Bush administration has shown its displeasure in the logistics arrangement of President Chen’s transit stop in the US in September 2007 on his way to Central America. Stephen Young even told the audience in Taipei that “there is a price to be paid in mutual trust” between Taipei and Washington. Although the UN referendum plan has provoked criticism from the US, it will not bring a structural change to US-Taiwan relations in the long term. President Chen is prepared to step down on May 20, 2008 and the US is ready to cooperate with the new Taiwan president as long as he is duly elected. Even President Hu Jintao in his mid-October political report of 17th Party Congress signaled that he is ready to achieve a peace agreement with Taiwan under the one China principle and suspends words of intimidations on Taiwan’s UN referendum. .

The US cares about Taiwan’s national security, but it has no intention of assisting Taiwan in expanding its room for diplomatic maneuvering. China always thinks it represents Taiwan internationally. Given this, Taiwan has to create its own path; otherwise, it will eventually be marginalized or downgraded into a part of PRC’s territory. For the US, an overreaction on Taiwan’s UN referendum will be suspected as collaborating with Beijing in jointly suppressing Taiwan’s international space, even though no one in Taiwan would claim that their endeavors will succeed in the UN referendum, let alone realizing UN membership for Taiwan in the near future.

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

The Formosan Association for Public Affairs (FAPA)

Founded in 1982 in Los Angeles, The Formosan Association for Public Affairs (FAPA) is a world-wide non-profit organization headquartered in Washington.

Aiming at establishing a democratic and secure Taiwan that is accepted as an equal in the international community, the goal of the FAPA are as follows(according to its info pamphlet):

1. to promote international support for the right of the people of Taiwan to establish an independent and democratic country, one that is a full-fledged member of the international community;
2. to advance the rights and interests of Taiwanese communities throughout the world; and
3. to promote the peace and security of Taiwan.

Additionally, the FAPA aims to enhance the welfare and recognition of Taiwanese-Americans in the USA as well. As for the FAPA educational program, it includes publishing newsletters and occasional press releases and opinion pieces, organizing workshops and speeches, participating in important conferences concerning Taiwan, and directly meeting with policy makers both in the USA and Taiwan.

Moreover, the FAPA pays close attention to the following issues:

HUMAN RIGHTS: During the dark days of KMT-imposed martial law, the FAPA pressed for an end to KMT control of the media, the release of political prisoners, and a cessation of the “blacklisting” that kept overseas Taiwanese activists from returning to Taiwan. In so doing, the people of Taiwan would enjoy basic freedoms and human rights.

DEMOCRACY: Taiwan experienced a peaceful transfer of power from one party to another in 2000 presidential election, marking the sure sign of a mature democracy. As early as 1986, the FAPA urged the USA Congress to organize the “Committee for Democracy on Taiwan” to promote human rights, freedom and democracy. Meanwhile, the FAPA also worked with the USA Congress to pressure the KMT regime to accelerate progress toward a fully democratic system in Taiwan.

SECURITY: On the grounds that China has refused to renounce the use of force against Taiwan, the FAPA also makes efforts to insure that policy makers in the USA and the American public can understand the moral and legal obligations that bind the USA and Taiwan, as well as Taiwan’s strategic importance.

SELF-DETERMINATION: More importantly, the people of Taiwan should have the right to determine their own future. The sovereignty over Taiwan and the Pescadores is still unsettled, since The San Francisco Peace Treaty of 1951 only stipulated that Japan renounce “all right, title and claim to [Taiwan]” but did not specify the recipient. The FAPA believes that the Taiwanese have the right of self-determination enshrined in the U.N. Charter, and that the USA should abandon the so-called “One China Policy” and instead adopt a “One China, One Taiwan Policy."

Friday, October 26, 2007

The referendum on Taiwan's UN bid and "One China" Policy

Taiwan President Chen Shui-bian addressed that Taiwan’s pushing for the referendum on its bid to join the UN under the name “Taiwan” will allow both the USA and China to re-evaluate the "One China" policy.



President Chen and Vice President Lu joining U.N. bid torch relay on Oct. 24th





The cover of “Deconstructuring One China”





Last month, a book titled “Deconstructuring ‘One China’: Theoretical, Comparative and Historical Studies” that I co-edited with Ms. Yun-wen Soong had been published and caught many attentions. This book aims to re-think and re-evaluate the so-called “One China” policy that has been detrimental to the development of Taiwan’s foreign relations, and addresses the importance of deconstructuring the “One China” framework manipulated by the Beijing authority in the international arena.

Taiwan’s President Chen Shui-bian also echoed the ideas emphasized in the book by addressing that Taiwan’s pushing for the referendum on Taiwan's bid to join the UN under the name “Taiwan” will allow the USA to re-evaluate its "One China" policy.

Under the influence of the referendum on Taiwan’s UN bid, President Chen claimed that Washington will certainly review the "One China" policy that has been in favor of the People's Republic of China and consider whether or not the USA should politically recognize both China and Taiwan.

The DPP-proposed referendum on whether to join the UN under the name Taiwan is slated to be held alongside Taiwan’s presidential election on March 22 next year. Chen believes that the passage of the ruling DPP-initiated UN bid referendum will be very helpful for winning USA’s support for Taiwan.

In addition, President Chen also claimed that once the referendum’s result shows that most of the Taiwanese support Taiwan to enter the UN under the name of Taiwan, the PRC will no longer insist on the "One China" prerequisite for cross-strait negotiations.

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

A Dual Race of Taiwan’s Referendum on UN Bid

Taiwan’s referendum on UN bid is a “dual race” involving a competition between domestic as well as international politics; these two factors are influenced by each other, like a “two-level game” addressed by Harvard Professor Robert Putnam.

According to the survey conducted by the Taiwan Thinktank, the Taiwanese public put much weight on the “Join UN Referendum.” For example, the survey shows that more than 50% of the population believed that the referendum could be very helpful in maintaining the peace across the Taiwan Strait. In addition, a question regarding the KMT and the DPP shows that 87% of DPP supporters favored the Join UN Referendum, while only 35% of KMT supporters favored this referendum. These results clearly displayed different positions between the DPP and the KMT.

However, inside the KMT, the level of support towards the referendum was divided. The Join UN Referendum, besides being a key election factor, has so far created many differences in opinion within the KMT. This example was seen when Taipei City Mayor Hau Lung-pin reacted immediately against the referendum when he arrived in Singapore and when Taichung Mayor Jason Hu spoke against the referendum. The internal differences within the KMT may cause the KMT to lose its sense of propriety. As soon as the KMT’s basic values are in conflict with its election strategy, problems will certainly surface.

In addition, one can observe that the KMT supporters tend to follow the U.S. in terms of opposing the referendum. On the contrary, international pressure has no such an influence on DPP supporters. After the U.S. expressed their opposition towards the referendum, 90% of DPP supporters still supported the idea of holding a referendum on Taiwan’s UN bid. Therefore, in the race of domestic politics, international pressure is an important factor in affecting the thinking of KMT supporters, while foreign influence is not an issue for DPP supporters. In fact, the good feeling towards the U.S. has already started to decline in Taiwan. Thus, if the U.S. is unable to influence Taiwan’s domestic politics or to improve its self-image in Taiwan, what are the U.S.’s political benefits anyway? It is necessary for the U.S. to contemplate upon this.

Nonetheless, do Taiwanese people believe that the Join UN Referendum is equal to moving towards independence? There is a great discrepancy in this statement. The survey does not delve deep enough to reach a conclusion. In my view, Taiwan holding a referendum is unable to escape two types of value conclusions: the first one involves Taiwan independence and the second, democratic ideology. Interestingly, the DPP achieved the common divisor in these two values. That is, the Taiwan Join UN Referendum won simultaneously both Taiwan independence supporters and democracy advocates.

In simple terms, the Join UN Referendum will not only express a part of the value towards Taiwan independence and democratic ideology, but also the demands for international space from the Taiwanese public. The international race points a finger at U.S.-China-Taiwan relations, while the domestic race intensifies public will towards the Join UN referendum with the inclusion of disputes between political parties. It will be worthy to observe different standpoints shown by this dual race and the influence these two races have on each other.

Monday, September 17, 2007

US representatives support Taiwan UN bid

Taiwan possesses all the qualifications to become a UN member—it is not only a free, open and independent democracy, but also a good neighbor and friend to countries in need around the world.

Some US Congress members expressed their support for Taiwan's bid to gain membership in the UN ahead of a rally promoting the bid in New York.

In a letter to the Formosan Association for Public Affairs (FAPA), one of the rally's main organizers, US Representative Anthony Weiner said he deeply regretted that the UN continues to disregard Taiwan’s sovereignty and deny the right of self-determination to the Taiwanese.

"There is no question that the United States must stand strong and advocate Taiwan's independence from China and inclusion as a United Nations member state," Weiner stressed.

Representative Dana Rohrabacher said it was incongruous that the UN—founded on the principles of universality and self-determination—would exclude a free, democratic and independent nation whose population is larger than three-quarters of the UN' member states.

Rohrabacher emphasized that Taiwan possesses all the qualifications to become a UN member and ample resources to contribute to the UN.

Also writing to FAPA, US Representative Edolphus Towns said that Taiwan is not only a free, open and independent democracy, but also a good neighbor and friend to countries in need around the world.

Towns said Taiwan’s people, who have demonstrated they are responsible citizens of the world, deserve a voice and a seat at the UN.

Another Representative Robert Andrews said "China must recognize that Taiwan is neither rival nor vassal. Rather, it is a neighbor," Andrews said.

Taiwan has not been represented in the UN since 1971, when the Republic of China's UN seat was replaced by the People's Republic of China.

This year, Taiwan is bidding to join the world body under the name "Taiwan."
On July 19th, Taiwan President Chen Shui-bian sent a membership application letter to UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon; however, the letter was returned on the grounds that the UN follows a "one China" policy.

Throwing their weight behind Taiwan, some of the country's diplomatic allies submitted a motion to the UN General Assembly last month, requesting that the Security Council process Taiwan's membership application according to established procedures, in the hope that the motion could be included as a supplementary item in the agenda of the 62nd regular session of the General Assembly set to open on September 18th.

(Excerpts from Taipei Times)

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

US President Bush Lauds Taiwan’s Democratic Development at the APEC

After Washington kept expressing its opposition to Taiwan’s UN bid referendum, US President George W. Bush addressed that Taiwan should be regarded as leading US defense partner and an example of democratic development that China could follow and as a leading US defense partner.

At a business summit of the APEC meeting last Thursday, President Bush further added that the US’ relationship with Taiwan, along with other nations in the region, forms “the bedrock of America’s engagement in Asia-Pacific.”

In his speech aiming at promoting greater democracy, freedom and prosperity in the region, Bush also praised that Taiwan’s emergence as a democratic society could urge China to “show confidence by demonstrating a commitment to greater openness and tolerance.”

Moreover, Bush mentioned that the US alliances with Australia, Japan, South Korea, Thailand and the Philippines, and its defense relationships with Singapore, Taiwan, Indonesia and other countries in the region have formed the bedrock of US’ engagement in the Asia-Pacific.

In his view, the aforesaid security relationships have helped maintain the peace in this region, and they also have created conditions allowing freedom and democracy to expand, markets to grow, and commerce to flow.

Bush then termed Taiwan’s evolution into a democracy, “one of the great stories of our time.”

Noting that at the end of World War II, Australia and New Zealand were the only democracies in Asia, Bush said: “Since then, we have witnessed Japan’s transformation into a thriving free society, the triumph of democracy in the Philippines [and] democratic transitions in Taiwan, South Korea and Indonesia.”

He also said the US will encourage China to open up its political system and give greater voice to its people. Bush pointed out the US relationships with South Korea and Taiwan during the Cold War period had already proved that it is possible to maintain friendships while pushing toward democracy.

Additionally, in the speech, Bush proposed a new “Asia Pacific Democracy Partnership,” in which free nations aim to work together to support democratic values , to strengthen democratic institutions and to assist those who are working to build and sustain free societies across the Asia-Pacific region.

Commenting on Bush’s speech, Dr. Johnny Chiang (江啟臣), a research fellow at the Chinese Taipei APEC Study Center, said: “Through the speech, Bush warned China in a highly skillful way.”

Dr. Chiang pointed out that by emphasizing democracy at the beginning of the speech, Bush actually expressed the US’ position that it would not compromise democracy and would try to block China’s rise with the US democratic allies. Moreover, by saying one of the best ways to strengthen freedom and prosperity in the Asia-Pacific region is through the expansion of trade and investment, Bush was indicating free trade should be established on democracy, Chiang stressed.

(Excerpts from Taipei Times)

Monday, September 10, 2007

US stance risks hostile responses in Taiwan

US Deputy Secretary of State John Negroponte has criticized moves toward holding a referendum on applying for UN membership under the name “Taiwan.” This is an important warning regarding the relations between Taiwan and the US, and we should pay close attention to what follows.

Negroponte’s statements bring to mind former secretary of state Colin Powell's interview with Hong Kong’s Phoenix Television in October 2004. Powell said at the time: “There is only one China. Taiwan is not independent. It does not enjoy sovereignty as a nation.”

Recently, with statements like Negroponte’s that a referendum is “a step towards the declaration of independence of Taiwan,” or by Dennis Wilder, the senior director of East Asian Affairs on the US’ National Security Council, that: “Taiwan, or the Republic of China, is not at this point a state,” Washington has virtually become a mouthpiece for the Chinese government. It is increasingly obvious that China uses the US government to put pressure on Taiwan.

The problem is that the US is willing to oppress Taiwanese democracy rather than muster up the will or the courage to take a stand against China’s arbitrary and unreasonable demands. And when the US chooses the side of China, relations between Taiwan and the US cannot avoid a structural change.

However, for a long time Taiwan was different from other Asian countries in that it had no strong national anti-US feeling or movement.

It is therefore worth examining how the US government’s position brushes aside the manifestation of the will of the Taiwanese public and harms relations between Taiwan and the US.

With the US and China standing together in preventing Taiwan from breaking out of its diplomatic isolation, feelings of dislike and distrust are growing among Taiwanese. Some polls in Taiwan illustrate this development. The favorable impression the Taiwanese have of the US is steadily weakening, and anti-US sentiment is brewing.

In the interview with Phoenix Television, Negroponte said that “Taiwan has no better friend than the United States.” But Washington often disregards the fact that for a long time, Taiwan has been the US’ most reliable friend. The US seems to take Taiwan’s support and cooperation for granted, while disregarding what Taiwan stands for and what it wants. US opposition to Taiwan holding a referendum on UN membership reflects this arrogant attitude.

The biggest blind spot the US has regarding Taiwan is that it does not know how to deal with its democracy and its people. It still believes that by putting pressure on Taiwan’s leaders it can change policy. This is exactly the mistake that the US most often warns the leaders in Beijing against.

Washington has to understand that when it criticizes Taipei and says that pushing for a referendum is a mistake, it not only criticizes President Chen, but also all Taiwanese who support having a referendum.

Rhetoric that seeks to separate Chen from the public only serves to show how little the US, one of the world’s foremost democracies, understands democracy.

Unfortunately, arrogance and lack of understanding on the part of the US only makes Taiwanese feel angry and frustrated. One needs to beware that when anti-US sentiment emerges in Taiwan, it could gradually evolve into anti-Americanism, and this in turn could influence Taiwan’s strategic choices.

This might be the most important factor in structural changes in the relationship between Taiwan and the US.

(From Taipei Times 09/08/2007)

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Taiwanese urged the US to back Taiwan's U.N. bid

“The US is a democratic country where referendums are held when elections are around the corner. Even if Taiwan is not a country, Taiwan still has the right to hold a referendum without consent from other countries. Unless the US sees Taiwan as its colony, how can the US say no to Taiwan’s UN referendum bid?”

Members of a civic group promoting Taiwan’s UN bid joined some Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) legislators in front of the American Institute in Taiwan (AIT) yesterday to protest against the US opposition to Taiwan’s plan to hold a referendum on the issue regarding applying for the UN membership under the name “Taiwan.”

Representatives of the UN for Taiwan Alliance also submitted a protest letter to Thomas Hodges, the AIT’s spokesman. The representatives told Hodges that they deeply regretted the US government’s objections, particularly considering the long friendship between the two countries.

The representatives stressed that the Taiwanese people’s resolve to push for the referendum will not be thwarted, and in the meantime, they urged the US government to understand and support Taiwan’s effort to become a full and equal member of the world body.

Twu Shiing-jer, secretary-general of the alliance, said that US officials’ remarks concerning Taiwan’s referendum plan have denied the rights of Taiwan’s people and overlooked Taiwan’s status as an independent sovereign state. Twu also addressed that applying for UN membership is a major step to furthering Taiwan’s democracy, and the US should not yield to China’s unreasonable requests.

However, Hodges repeated a statement made last week by US Deputy Secretary of State John Negroponte that Washington is opposed to the referendum because the US sees it as a step “towards a declaration of independence of Taiwan and an alteration of the status quo.”
DPP legislator Kao Chieh-chih said, “The US is of course entitled to safeguard its own interests, but it cannot do so at the cost of Taiwan’s rights.”

Several pro-independence civil groups have planned to launch a mass march in Taipei this Saturday; they will protest in front of the AIT to demand that the US respect the Taiwanese’ choice of freedom and autonomy.

(Excerpts from Taiwan News)

Tuesday, September 4, 2007

Is Washington Serious about Supporting Democracy around the World?

Last month, deputy US secretary of state John Negroponte had an interview with Phoenix Television in Hong Kong. Although Negroponte did emphasize the friendship between Taiwan and the US, still, he expressed the US opposition to the proposed referendum plan regarding Taiwan’s bid on joining the UN under the name “Taiwan.”

Obviously, Negroponte fails to understand that Taiwan’s UN referendum underlines the Taiwanese’ desire for their country to be a full member in the international community instead of being isolated internationally.

According to Gerrit van der Wees, the editor of Taiwan Communique, the US administration is now playing into China’s hands while frustrating those in Taiwan who have worked long and hard to achieve democracy. He stressed that the reason the US is playing into China’s hands is because Beijing has been manipulating the US to do its bidding. From China’s perspective, as Taiwan democracy grows, Beijing has less influence over Taiwan. Thus, their strategy is to force the US to restrain Taiwan’s democracy.

Applying for the UN membership has been a very important issue for Taiwan’s government and people, and by holding a referendum, it will allow the US and the international community to have a good understanding of how the Taiwanese people view this issue. Moreover, it can be a good example for the Chinese to see how democracy works.

It is a pity that Dennis Wilder, senior director for Asian Affairs at the US National Security Council, said that membership in the UN requires statehood, and Taiwan or the Republic of China “is not at this point a state in the international community.” In his article, Gerrit van der Wees further argues that like many policymakers in the international society, Wilder fails to distinguish “being a state” from “recognition by other nations.”

Van der Wees further gives us an example: the most authoritative definition of the “nation state” is given in the 1933 Montevideo Convention on Rights and Duties of States, to which the US is a signatory. The convention’s definition of a nation state is as follows: 1) a defined territory, 2) a permanent population and 3) a government capable of entering into relations with other states.

There is no doubt that Taiwan fulfills all the three requirements mentioned above. Therefore, Taiwan is a nation-state.

After undergoing a remarkable transition to democracy in the 1990s, Taiwan is now a free and democratic country. As such, the Taiwan government deserves to be recognized in the international community. Taiwan’s future, nevertheless, cannot be dictated by the Chinese Communist Party which has no sense of human rights, democracy and so on.

We hope that if the US and other democratic countries are serious about supporting democracy around the world, then they must stand up for their basic principles of human rights, freedom and democracy, and in so doing support Taiwan’s wish to join international organizations like the WHO and the UN.

Monday, September 3, 2007

Referendum on Taiwan's UN bid and Taiwan-US Relations : Has the US become China's Spokesman ?

Taiwan’s plan to hold a referundum on joining the UN under the name “Taiwan” has made the relations between Taiwan and the US go through a shaky period. Throughout this process, one can observe that the US’ scale has gradually tilted more toward China. However, this change in American foreign policy has not only harmed the US relationship with its most loyal friend in Asia but also damaged the interests of the US. Although China appreciates the US opposition to Taiwan’s referendum plan, many allies of the US in Asia are perplexed by the US’ attitude. To some degree, the US has become China’s spokesman.

Undoubtedly, the geopolitics of Asia is beyond complicated. Politically, democratic and authoritatian countries exist side by side in the region of Asia. Economically, due to its fast growing economy, Asia has become the real driver of the global economic domain; ironcially, the richest and the poorest societies also co-exist in Asia. Moreover, since the 1990s, military spending in Asia has been increasing and shot to a record high. Asia in the 21st century is like Europe in the 19th century—various powers have risen, but a transnational security mechanism has not yet been established to control and alleviate regional tensions in Asia.

Taiwan has a very unique strategic geopolitical position in East Asia. During the past sixty years, Taiwan has been under the military threats of China but in the mean time made great efforts in achieving politcial democraticization and economic modernization. In addition, Taiwan has been selfishlessly sharing its development experience with the international community, and has maintained mutually harmonious and prosperous relations with other countries. Moreover, Taiwan always obeys the UN charter and the regulation of international laws, as well as promotes regional stability and peace.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

Democratic Taiwan deserves an UN seat and the right to hold UN referendum

John Negroponte, the US Deputy Secretary of State, made the US stance on Taiwan’s UN referendum known on Monday, branding the referendum proposal a “mistake.” He warned that the referendum would be viewed by the US government as an attempt to change “status quo” across the Taiwan Strait.

However, Taiwan President Chen Shui-bian stressed that the aim of this referendum proposal would be to protect Taiwan’s status quo so as to avoid China’s aggression. In his view, “Taiwan” is the most appropriate and familiar name for the country to take part in international organizations. President Chen has been reiterating that applying to enter the UN under the name of Taiwan will not violate his “for noes” commitments to the US.

The US State Department has been very frustrated with President Chen’s push for the referendum and considers him to be a “trouble-maker.” The Washington keeps repeating its opposition to Taiwan’s plan to hold UN referendum and claims that in so doing the tensions between China and Taiwan will be intensified.

Nevertheless, what the US officials cannot realize is that President Chen is acting on behalf of the 23 million people of Taiwan. According to various public polls, more than 70% of the Taiwan citizens think that Taiwan should apply to enter the UN under the name of “Taiwan.” For instance, a survey carried out by the Taiwan Thinktank earlier this year suggested that more than 75% of Taiwanese expressed support for the idea of holding a referendum on Taiwan’s UN bid. Another survey commissioned by the Institute for National Policy Research and conducted by the ERA Survey Research Center in June showed that more than 70% of respondents supported the government’s UN bid under the name of Taiwan as well.

Certainly, as an elected president of a democratic country, President Chen has the responsibility to follow the mainstream opinion and look out for the Taiwanese’s best interests. It is his duty to follow the Taiwan people’s call for the universal values such as democracy, freedom of opinion, and respect for human rights.

It is a pity that the US has come under increasing pressure from the PRC on many aspects of the cross-strait issues, including Taiwan’s UN referendum proposal. An Taipei Times editorial today criticizes that it is ironic for the Beijing authority to trumpet that the PRC “places its hope in the people of Taiwan” but in the mean time has the fear in having the people of Taiwan raise their collective voice to tell the international community about what they truly want. And sadly, the US yields to China’s pressure and fails to see Taiwan’s UN referendum proposal as a way to consolidate democracy in Taiwan.

The editorial further points out that the US’ claim of “supporting Taiwan’s democracy” seems to be hysterical, on the grounds that the US government—as the leading promoter of democracy in the world—strongly opposes Taiwan’s referendum plan and shows no respect for the will of the Taiwanese people.

An official government press release also stresses that Taiwan’s democratically elected government is the only legitimate government that can represent the interests and wishes of the people of Taiwan. However, the UN and many countries in the world still neglect the voice of the Taiwanese and exclude Taiwan from the UN. This exclusion constitutes discrimination against the Taiwanese and deprives them of their fundamental right. To protect the interests of the 23 million people of Taiwan, there is an urgent need to examine this odd situation and to redress this mistaken omission.

At present, the US is busy with its global war on terrorism as well as maintaining a good relationship with the rising China, so the US does not want Taiwan to create any “troubles” and thus suppresses Taiwan’s referendum plan and its will of applying for the UN membership under the name of Taiwan. But, is it morally legitimate for the US and other countries to ignore the fact that China continues to spare no effort to suppress Taiwan in the international arena?

We argue that “normal states” in the world have no right to criticize Taiwan’s efforts in attaining a normal status in the international community. Taiwan firmly holds the commanding point of morality and humanity, because it is a democratic country that respects human rights and freedom of opinion and speech. Hence, we support Taiwan’s plan to hold a referendum on UN membership and the Taiwan people’s wish to exercise this universal right.

Wednesday, August 15, 2007

Referendum on Taiwan’s UN Bid and Cross-Strait Relations

Currently, the U.S. does not think that Taiwan’s international relations represent the most pressing issue in terms of regional or global security threats. It is quite obvious that the U.S.’s cross-strait policy aims at preventing a crisis from taking place in the Taiwan Strait—especially China’s using force to threaten Taiwan. However, in the short run, the U.S. must deal with cross-strait matters and the 2008 referendum on Taiwan’s bid to join the UN under the name of Taiwan.

Recently, the U.S. government has been against using the name of “Taiwan” to join the WHO and UN. The U.S. believes that the following negative effects might occur once the UN referendum is conducted: 1) Beijing’s attitude will become tougher, 2) Cross-strait relations will deteriorate further, 3) Taiwan’s international position will be even more isolated, and 4) In order to clearly declare their standpoints, the U.S. will try to convince other countries to oppose Taiwan’s UN referendum.

In addition, the U.S. has not expressed any concern for Taiwan’s current bilateral or multi-lateral international relations; much less, they have not given Taiwan any specific, clear, definite or strong support. In 1971, given all the efforts to protect Taiwan from having a seat in the UN, in an arrogant and lightly neglectful thinking—while China did not press on—the U.S. publicly expressed that they did not support Taiwan to enter the UN. It was indeed, in my view, an inconsistent policy that would spin a cocoon round the U.S. itself.

The Taiwan Relations Act states: “Nothing in this Act may be construed as a basis for supporting the exclusion or expulsion of Taiwan from continued membership in any international financial institution or any other international organization.” Nevertheless, the U.S. allowed the expulsion of Taiwan in 1980 from the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. In Shanghai in 1998, Clinton said the U.S. would not support Taiwan to join the UN or other international organizations, shackling both the U.S. and Taiwan and also implying a U.S. twist in the Taiwan Relations Act.

Taiwan’s changing domestic politics, especially the KMT’s support for the referendum, has made the Taiwan-U.S. relations even more complex. The DPP version of the referendum states: “In 1971, the People’s Republic of China entered the UN and replaced the Republic of China, making Taiwan an international orphan. In order to strongly express the will of the Taiwanese people and to promote Taiwan’s international participation, do you agree that the government should use the name of ‘Taiwan’ to join the UN?” And the KMT Central Standing Committee passed a set of regulations concerning the referendum in July 2007: “To create a more pragmatic and flexible strategy to return to the UN and to enter other international organizations.” Consequently, the U.S. and China have lost an important lever to check Taiwan. Therefore, it can be seen that when both of the DDP and KMT’s standpoints about joining international organizations converge, it could hold up the U.S. and China’s reactions toward Taiwan’s UN referendum. However, the U.S. and China’s together opposing Taiwan’s referendum or publicly supposing the referendum as “crossing the red line” has undoubtedly put tremendous pressure on Taiwan. If both the DPP and the KMT unanimously face the outside world together, the aforesaid situation might change.

At any rate, U.S.-Taiwan relations have once again reached a low point. Regarding President Chen’s request for application to UN membership, the PRC responded through a statement made by the Taiwan Work Office of the Communist Party of China Central Committee and the Taiwan Affairs Office of the State Council, which stated: “The Taiwan authorities under Chen Shui-bian, whether applying or promoting a referendum to join the UN, are plots and strategies move towards independence and to change the status quo—that is, the Mainland and Taiwan are part of one China.

All these actions aim to internally establish Taiwan independence and externally create better conditions to seek international recognition.” Beijing also threatened by saying that they have “made resolute preventions and necessary preparations against all Taiwan independence adventures.” Beijing avoided in mentioning the Anti-Secession Law and said that they would continue observing the 2008 referendum to join the UN. Additionally, Beijing’s academia specialists passed on a clear statement, stressing that it was impossible for them not to respond even though the reaction would damage the KMT.

Taiwan’s request for UN membership does have multiple meanings and are absolutely not, like Beijing said, plots for Taiwan independence. The request for application, even though frustrated, represents a right, a duty, a way out, a matter regarding national security, and Taiwan’s dignity. These considerations can never be understood by arrogant powers such as the U.S. and China.

Tuesday, August 7, 2007

US position on Taiwan's UN bid and referendum remains unchanged

The U.S. has been opposed to Taiwan’s referendum on using the name of “Taiwan” to join the UN. So far the U.S. has not expressed any concern for Taiwan’s current bilateral or multi-lateral international relations; much less, they have not given Taiwan any specific, clear, definite or strong support.

In 1971, in an arrogant and lightly neglectful thinking—while China did not press on—the U.S. clearly expressed that they did not support Taiwan to enter the UN. It was indeed inconsistent with the U.S’s previous policy during the cold war period. Although the Taiwan Relations Act states that nothing in the Act may be construed as a basis for supporting the exclusion or expulsion of Taiwan from continued membership in any international financial institution or any other international organization, still, the U.S. allowed the expulsion of Taiwan from the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund to happen in 1980. Moreover, in 1998 when Clinton visited Shanghai, he stressed that the U.S. would not support Taiwan to join the UN or other international organizations, showing a twist of the Taiwan Relations Act.

Currently, the U.S. does not view Taiwan’s international relations as the most pressing issue in terms of causing regional or global security threats. However, in the short run, the U.S. must deal with cross-strait matters due to the possible 2008 referendum on Taiwan’s bid to join the UN under the name of Taiwan. It is quite obvious that the U.S.’s cross-strait policy aims at preventing a crisis from taking place in the Taiwan Strait—especially China’s using force to threaten Taiwan. The U.S. believes that a referendum would be dangerously change the status quo and create the following negative impacts once the UN referendum is held: 1) Beijing’s attitude will become tougher, 2) Cross-strait relations will deteriorate further, 3) Taiwan’s international position will be even more isolated, and 4) The U.S. will be forced to convince other countries to oppose Taiwan’s UN referendum.

The DPP version of the referendum states: “In 1971, the PRC entered the UN and replaced the ROC, making Taiwan an international orphan. In order to strongly express the will of the Taiwanese people and to promote Taiwan’s international participation, do you agree that the government should use the name of ‘Taiwan’ to join the UN?” On the KMT’s side, it proposed its own UN referendum, and in July 2007 the KMT Central Standing Committee has passed a set of regulations concerning the referendum, such as “creating a more pragmatic and flexible strategy to return to the UN and to enter other international organizations.” The KMT’s support for the referendum, ironically, has made the Taiwan-U.S. relations even more complex. The U.S. and China, as a result, have lost an important lever to check Taiwan. Therefore, it can be seen that when both of the DDP and KMT’s standpoints about joining international organizations converge, it could more or less curb the U.S. and China’s political interference.

Nevertheless, the U.S. and China’s together opposing Taiwan’s referendum and supposing the referendum as “crossing the red line” have undoubtedly put tremendous pressure on Taiwan. If both the DPP and the KMT can share the same standpoint when facing the international community, other countries’ attitudes toward the Taiwan’s UN referendum might have a positive change.

Monday, July 9, 2007

The US won't tie Chen's transit stop to the UN referendum

In today’s Taiwan News, it reports that the US government will not downgrade the treatment of during his stopover in the US next month. It seems that Washington won’t tie Chen’s transit stop to the UN referendum issue, according to Joseph Wu, Taiwan's top envoy to the US. Chen is scheduled to visit Honduras in late August to attend a meeting between Taiwan and its diplomatic allies in Central America.

In a press conference held last week, Wu mentioned that Taiwan’s Vice President Annette Lu was greeted with due courtesy when she stayed in San Francisco overnight last week on her route to Latin America. Therefore, in his view, the US has separated the transit plan from the referendum proposal that aims to ask voters whether or not Taiwan should seek to rejoin the UN under the name of “Taiwan.”