Showing posts with label UN Interviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UN Interviews. Show all posts

Thursday, October 4, 2007

Report of the Taiwan-Africa Summit

Faced with China's diplomatic dominance in Africa, Taiwan cannot rely on winning allies through financial assistance, analysts said yesterday, adding that the nation should seek other forms of strategic partnership.

The first Taiwan-Africa Summit, held in Taipei last month, attended by the nation's five African diplomatic allies, concluded with the signing of a declaration supporting Taiwan's efforts to gain entry to the UN.

Taiwan's diplomatic allies in Africa are Malawi, Swaziland, Gambia, Burkina Faso and Sao Tome and Principe.

The paradox of China’s aid in Africa
Commenting on why these countries had chosen to maintain ties with Taiwan instead of China, Soochow University political science professor Lo Chih-cheng said that they were all opposed to China's diplomatic strategy.

"The relationship between China and African countries is what critics call neo-colonialism," Lo said. In exchange for securing energy and raw materials, Lo said China has been doling out aid and interest-free loans to African countries.

Following the summit, the government hosted a “Taiwan-African Progressive Partnership Forum,” attracting representatives from 40 countries, 35 of which do not have diplomatic relations with Taiwan and were pressured by China not to attend the event.

Chinese President Hu Jintao promised to double China's aid to Africa from last year's level by 2009 at the Forum of China-Africa Cooperation held in Beijing last November. The package included US$3 billion in loans, US$2 billion in export credits and a US$5 billion fund to encourage Chinese investment in Africa.

The Chinese also use the continent as a dumping ground for cheaply manufactured goods, Lo said, adding that China did not face complaints from African countries about poor quality, unlike the barrage of complaints it receives from Western countries.

While China has won many construction projects in Africa and created some jobs there, they often import their own workers.

Five categories of China’s allies in Africa
Yen Chen-shen, a research fellow at the Institute of International Relations at National Chengchi University, said that African countries without diplomatic relations with Taiwan could be divided into five different categories.

Some of the countries are caught in bloody civil wars and require UN peace-keeping forces. China, which is a permanent member of the UN Security Council, can use its veto power on peace-keeping issues as leverage with those countries.

This was what led Liberia to switch diplomatic relations from Taiwan to China in October 2003, Yen said.

The second group consists of countries rich in natural resources such as Sudan, Chad and Nigeria. Chad, rich in petroleum reserves, recognized China last year. China's African allies provide it with 25 percent of its oil imports.

With a phenomenal economic growth rate of 9 percent per annum, oil imports accounted for 47 percent of China's total consumption in the first half of last year.

Countries with an ambition to gain international influence comprise the third group, Yen said. Senegal, which ended diplomatic relations with Taiwan in October 2005, has replaced the Ivory Coast as the leading French-speaking force on the continent since the latter's political situation worsened in September 2002.

Countries that are too big for Taiwan to handle make up the fourth group, Yen said. Nigeria, for example, has a population six times that of Taiwan and a land area 22 times bigger.

The fifth group consists of countries that have a long relationship with China, such as Mali, which has connections with China because it was once socialist. Problems under Mali's socialist government led to a military coup in 1968. Another coup in 1991 brought a democratic government and a free market economy.

Because China has 48 allies to take care of in Africa, Yen said that each of Taiwan's five African allies gets more attention and more assistance.

"It is wise for them to stay with us," he said.

Taiwan’s Diplomatic Strategy
On the issue of how Taiwan should act to combat China's oppression, Lo said that the nation should consider cooperating with European and Latin American countries to stop China's growing power.

In addition, Taiwan must adjust its strategy and offer other countries what China cannot.

Domestically, the nation must decide whether it wants to channel more funds toward efforts to secure diplomatic ties or toward alternative assistance.

Yen agreed, saying that although democracy is Taiwan's advantage, it is "useless" in Africa.

The nation can, however, make good use of its advantages in high-tech industries and healthcare to build better relations with African countries, Yen said.

Describing China as a "new imperialist," Yen said the nation should make it clear to African countries that Taiwan would not damage their economies by sending illegal immigrants to run businesses there, which would drive up unemployment.

Yen said that he did not think Taiwan's diplomatic strategy required an overhaul, but added that the administration should put less pressure on diplomatic allies to pursue its political agenda.

Although the nation's bid for UN membership faces formidable obstacles, Yen said the administration's over-emphasis on the issue could end up working against it if it pushes the issue in its diplomatic strategy.

Lin Teh-chang, director of the Center for International NGO Studies, said he agreed that Taiwan must tweak its diplomatic strategy.

Although China has more African allies than Taiwan, Beijing's disregard for people's livelihoods, as well as its atrocious human rights record and its backing of abusive regimes, leaves a door open for Taiwan, Yen said.

The government, however, has long ignored this advantage, he said, adding that it is time to allocate more resources to develop relationships with the private sector and NGOs in Africa.

Such relations may take time to develop into official ties, but the effort will eventually pay off, he said.

(Excerpts from Taipei Times)

Friday, August 24, 2007

President Chen: Taiwan is already independent

“Taiwan is already a sovereign independent country. Our sovereignty does not fall under the jurisdiction of the People’s Republic of China (PRC). There is one country on each side of the Taiwan Strait. This is the status quo and this is the reality.”

Taiwan President Chen Shui-bian made the remarks above when he was asked in an interview with the BBC if Taiwan would declare independence. Namely in his view, Taiwan does not have to declare independence, since it is already independent.

BBC: ….Can, then, Taiwan ever become independent? Such a move would be suicidal, and it might even provoke a war between China and the United States.

President Chen:
Taiwan is already a sovereign independent country. Our sovereignty does not fall under the jurisdiction of the People's Republic of China (PRC). There is one country on each side of the Taiwan Strait. This is the status quo and this is the reality.

Taiwan, being a sovereign independent country, has a population of 23 million and covers an area of 36,000 square kilometers. Its sovereignty belongs to, and is vested in, the 23 million people of Taiwan. Taiwan's sovereignty does not belong to the PRC, nor does it belong to the 1.3 billion people of China.

If Taiwan were not a country, how come we will be electing our next president, the leader of this nation, in the year 2008? Furthermore, at the end of this year, we will hold an election for members of the Legislative Yuan. Taiwan has its own president and parliamentary representatives who are directly elected by the people; we form our own government; we have our own sovereignty and our own military; we have our own currency and our own independent judiciary. How can anyone say that Taiwan is not a country?

Currently, Taiwan has formal diplomatic ties with 25 countries. Even though most countries in the world do not have formal diplomatic relations with Taiwan, that does not negate the fact and status quo of Taiwan's being a sovereign independent country. Even though Taiwan may not be a full member of the United Nations (UN) or the World Health Organization (WHO), this does not constitute a negation of the existence of Taiwan as a sovereign independent country.

Taiwan and its people will continue striving until we become a normal country that is accepted by international society.

BBC: You talk about membership of the United Nations, membership of the World Health Organization; what is the next step for Taiwan in achieving that status as a normal state, as you call it?

President Chen:
We will continue to make efforts towards ensuring the voice of our people is heard around the world, so that our aspiration and decades of longing will be heeded internationally. In this process, we must further consolidate the consensus of our people and gather together their collective force for all the world to see.

We have continued to knock at the doors of the UN and WHO, hoping that one day they would be opened to us. We know our missions will not be fulfilled easily but we will not be discouraged by current setbacks and will continue to work hard. We want to make sure that one day, the voice of our people will be heard in all corners of the world, if not today, then maybe tomorrow. This time we were unsuccessful, but we hope to succeed next time round. However long it takes, we will continue striving until we become a normal country that is accepted by international society.

(For the full contents of the interview, kindly see http://www.president.gov.tw/en/)

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Dr. Joseph Wu: Taiwan May Export Freedom

Compared to many countries in the world, Taiwan has an impressive economy. The country’s economy grew 4.6% in 2006, and it also has the world’s third-highest foreign currency reserves. In addition, less than 1% of Taiwan’s 23 million people live below the poverty line, and unemployment is about 3.9%.

However, the question mark is Taiwan’s growing dependence on China. Regardless of arguing if it is a bad or good thing, one major focus of debate in Taipei is about whether or not wealth and economic development will bring democracy to China.

China considers Taiwan a part of China rather than a sovereign country. Moreover, it has installed about 1,000 short-range missiles a little over 50 miles away across the Taiwan Strait, and it has even threatened war if Taiwan declares independence.

Meanwhile, Taiwan business—often guided by the profit principle rather than political ideals—has invested as much as $150 billion in China. At present, about 1 million Taiwanese—most of them are business people—live in China.

In the last two decades, Taiwan’s government has been trying to limit such investments, but the efforts are all in vain.

“It hasn’t worked,” said Joseph Wu, Taiwan’s unofficial ambassador to the United States—Taiwan does not have a formal diplomatic tie with the US, so Dr. Wu’s official title should be “Representative of the Taipei Economic and Cultural Representative Office” in Washington.

Dr. Wu, who got his doctorate in political science from Ohio State, has weighed the debate about economic growth and democracy throughout his career as a government official and academic. Now, he senses some changes are happening in China.

According to Dr. Wu, during the last couple of years, people have seen indications showing that the people in China desire to have more freedoms, such as freedoms of thought, speech, religion, and more economic freedom particularly. “There are a rising number of human rights lawyers in China, similar to Taiwan’s situation during the 1970s and 1980s. China might be on the verge of becoming more liberal politically, so economic growth might be the best tool to open things up,” Dr. Wu said.

Nevertheless, Taiwan’s ruling Democratic Progressive Party, which has Taiwan’s independence as its ultimate goal, wants to go slow with deepening economic ties to China. The Chinese authorities, instead, have been wooing the Kuomintang (Nationalist Party) and in so doing have created tensions between the DPP and KMT. The two sides will face off in a presidential election in 2008.

It is noteworthy that China will replace Canada by 2010 and become the largest trading partner of the United States. There is also an unsettled debate here in Washington over whether China should be seen as a strategic partner or a competitor of the US. The roots of the debate have the same flavor as Taiwan’s. In other words, it hinges on whether or not economic growth will bring democracy to the Mainland.

The question is existential for Taiwan and certainly has crucial implications for the US as well. Since late 1980s, the Chinese Communist Party has been trying hard to achieve rapid economic growth, while at the time surrendering little political power to its people. Some people worry that Chinese communism has found its path to permanence.

Dr. Wu suggested that we should wait a while longer. In his view, China deserves criticism for jailing religious dissidents, lawyers and journalists, doing too little to curb the Sudanese government’s barbarisms in Darfur as well as blocking Taiwan’s search for better economic and diplomatic ties with the world. “But, Chinese visitors from China go home impressed with the freedom and vigor of Taiwan’s democracy,” he said.

A patient Taiwan could wind up exporting something much more precious—namely democracy and freedom, Dr. Wu stressed.

(Excepts from The Dallas Morning News)

Thursday, August 9, 2007

Taiwan Seeking Peace and Human Rights in UN Bid (Part II)

Johannesburg, South Africa: About the exclusion of Taiwan from the UN, is it a political apartheid? How does it affect Taiwan’s people on a day-to-day basis?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: This is not just a political apartheid but also a health and environmental one. In Asia and all over the world, many countries are very concerned about the outbreak of the Avian flu in Asia, and the WHO is working hard on preventing that from happening. Unfortunately, Taiwan, not a member of the WHO (under the UN system), has been excluded from participating in this world health system.
________________

New York, N.Y.: How does the average Taiwanese person feel about Taiwan's exclusion? Is there a lot of anger or is it basically accepted as a fait accompli?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: We don’t accept it as a fait accompli. Our relentless efforts in the past 13 consecutive years show our determination. Frankly speaking, we see our exclusion from the UN as a discrimination against us.
________________

West Chester, Pa.: The PRC has taken a very hard stance on the recognition of Taiwan as a sovereign state. Is there any reason to believe that they can be dissuaded from this stance by any discussion with the UN acting as an intermediary?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: That is what Taiwan is hoping for. The UN should play some role in bringing the two sides of the Taiwan Strait to come to terms with each other and to reconcile their differences through peaceful means. However, so far, UN has refused to say or do anything about this.
________________

Priceton, N.J.: Even without a seat in the UN, it doesn't really affect both Taiwan's economic and democratic development. Can you explain why Taiwan needs to become a member of the UN?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: Taiwan would have done much better if it were a member of the UN. Remember, we don’t know the exact health costs paid by Taiwan until the SARS happened in 2003. We now realize that Taiwan’s exclusion from the WHO could be extremely costly.
________________

Santa Cruz, Calif.: We hear a lot in the American media about how your president wishes to unilaterally declare independence from China. Is this truly the case? And if so, how would Taiwan’s constitution figure into such a declaration?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: That is not correct. Our president has said that Taiwan has been a sovereign country and there is no need to declare the so-called “independence.”
________________

Hong Kong: Taiwan has made much about the fact that China has hundreds of missiles pointed at it. What is Taiwan doing to counter this threat?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: Taiwan has its own missile defense system. We want to continue to beef up our defense against China’s military threat. We have no intention to engage in any sort of arms races with China. What we have been doing is to maintain credible deterrence posture against any possible military attack from China.
________________

Boston, Mass: I would like to focus on Taiwan's peace proposal to the UN this year. Could you explain exactly how the UN could facilitate peace between Taiwan and China?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: Taiwan Strait has been called one of the “flash-points” in Asia. In this inter-dependent world, any tension or even military conflict in the Taiwan Strait could affect the whole region and the whole world. That is why we are calling the UN’s attention to the peace and security in the Taiwan Strait. I think the UN can bring the issue to the table for discussion, or even invite both Beijing and Taipei to talk to each other at the UN.
________________

Toronto, Canada: I cannot believe that China has the nerve to suppress Taiwan’s freedoms—for instance, continually blocking Taiwan's earnest bid to become a member of UN. I view myself as a Taiwanese-Canadian not a Chinese-Canadian. I support the right of Taiwan to gain entry. Taiwan should be a recognizable sovereign participant in the international community. My question is: in what ways can Canadians help to further Taiwan to achieve its goal?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: Thank you. We need your both moral and actual support. Please write to your government to show your support of our UN bid. Ask your government not to endorse, intentionally or unintentionally, Beijing’s efforts in isolating Taiwan in the world community. Thanks again.
_________________

Atlanta, Ga.: What is the current state of relations between Taiwan and China? Are there currently any high-level exchanges between the two?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: China has refused to have any government-to-government contacts between the two sides. As a result, there is no high-level exchange across the Taiwan Strait. Our government has been urging the Beijing side to talk to us, to no avail, however.
_________________

Diamond Bar, Calif.: China was recently infuriated with North Korea for de-stabliing the Korean Peninsula. North Korea’s missile tests caused regional panic and drew anger from China. Clearly an unstable Asian region adversely affects China’s economic goals. How does a growingly internationally dependent China affect the prospects of independence for Taiwan?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: The question has more to do with whether China can be more democratic than whether China is becoming interdependent with the world community. If China can become a democratic country, maybe China can be more willing to give a free choice to the people in Taiwan.

(Excerpts from Viewpoint, a live discussion forum on washingtonpost.com)

Wednesday, August 8, 2007

Taiwan Seeking peace and Human Rights in UN Bid (Part I)

By any definition, Taiwan is a sovereign country, yet it continues to be excluded from international organizations such as the United Nations. The democratic island nation's strained relations with its communist neighbor, the People's Republic of China, has turned the Taiwan Strait into a "flash-point" as potentially dangerous as the Middle East or the Korean Peninsula. Looking to protect peace and stability in East Asia, Taiwan now proposes that the UN take a proactive role similar to its actions in Lebanon and Korea to reduce cross-strait tensions.
_______________________

Washington, D.C.: What kind of support have you gotten from the United States on past UN bids?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: Unfortunately, nothing. The US does not support Taiwan’s membership at international organizations where “statehood” is a requirement. To be frank, I don’t think that is a right policy on the part of US government.

Trenton, N.J.: Could you explain how China works to keep Taiwan excluded from the UN?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: China uses both sticks and carrots to affect other countries’ attitudes on Taiwan’s UN bid. For instance, by giving foreign aid, Beijing has been wooing other countries to support its stance. For another instance, China sometimes uses trade and economic retaliation against others who support Taiwan.

Berlin, Germany: In the past few decades, Taiwan has grown up rapidly both in economy and politics, though without a seat in the UN, is it that necessary to campaign to participate in the UN again?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: It is precisely because Taiwan has grown in economy and politics that we wish to be a normal country recognized by the international community and able to contribute our achievements to the world. For example, Taiwan has been numbering a number of agricultural and medical foreign assistance projects, and we feel that our projects could be much more effective if coordinated with the various UN agencies.

Rockville, Md.: Under UN's current decision making system, China has veto power. And based on international real politics, it seems there is no hope for Taiwan's UN bid. Where does your confidence come from?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: We will never know. Taiwan (ROC) had the veto power at the UN Security Council before 1971. But China (PRC) still entered the UN that year. So, Taiwan has to keep trying. We never know what will happen in the future. Remember, nobody predicted the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Singapore: Taiwan seems to be tying this year's campaign to join the U.N. to human rights. Could you explain how Taiwan has come to see representation in the UN as a human rights issue?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: There are many functional international organizations under the UN umbrella. For instance, the WHO is a special agency under the UN. Because of Taiwan’s exclusion from the UN, Taiwan has been excluded from the world health system. So, you see the linkage between Taiwan’s UN membership and human rights issues.

Toronto, Canada: My husband and I visited your country a few years ago and fell in love with what we saw and were charmed by its friendly people. My question is, why has China been blocking Taiwan bid for so long when it knows its actions will only alienate the Taiwanese?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: You are absolutely right. China’s efforts in isolating Taiwan internationally only alienate the Taiwanese people. Beijing may believe that what it has been doing will force Taiwan to come to China’s terms. But, that is counter-productive. Anyway, thanks for your support. And please visit Taiwan again.

Christchurch, New Zealand: I have a two-part question. Are there any legal precedents that might help a contested territory like Taiwan join international organizations like the UN? How did Taiwan manage to join the World Trade Organization with its contested status?

Dr. Chih-cheng Lo: Good question. Both East Germany and West Germany were members of the UN before they were reunified in 1990. North Korea and South Korea are now both members of the UN. Unfortunately, China is playing a zero-sum game.

(Excerpts from Viewpoint, a live discussion forum on washingtonpost.com)