Showing posts with label Observations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Observations. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

The China Factor in Taiwan's Admission into the WHO

When I browsed the website of "Peace Forum" (www.peaceforum.org.tw), the following article attracted my attention.

As it mentioned, the main reason for Taiwan not being a member of the World Health Organization was China's boycott. In the past few years, China kept reiterating that there was only One China in the world, and therefore Taiwan couldn't be a part of the WHO.

So, it's obvious that who is putting politics above health rights, isn't it?

=======================================

The China Factor in Taiwan's Admission into the WHO

China is the biggest obstacle in Taiwan’s admission to the WHO

Under the current severe political confrontation, Taiwan’s bid for the WHO membership is one of the few issues that have high consensus in Taiwan society. Since 1997, the Taiwan government has adopted the policy of seeking admission into the WHO. But after 10 years of effort, Taiwan is still unable to achieve its goal. However, these efforts have brought this issue to the attention of the international community, and have gained support from friendly nations that are willing to assist Taiwan to become part of global cordon.

It is an undeniable fact that Taiwan’s biggest obstacle in joining the WHO is China’s blockage. Otherwise, as the world’s 15th biggest economy and a vibrant democracy, there is no reason for the WHO to refuse Taiwan’s membership bid. As a rising power, China has exerted enormous influences and pressure to drive Taiwan out of international arena by forcing the world to accept the so-called “One-China Policy.” The PRC has tried to make it as a “norm,” so as to deny Taiwan’s nationhood and sovereignty.

The methods China used to block Taiwan’s participation

1) International Law Argument:

The PRC has always argued that the UN Resolution 2758 and its derivative laws have declined Taiwan’s sovereign nation status and abolished Taiwan’s right to participate in organizations that require nationhood, including the WHO.
......(full text)

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Taipei Times: China's `concern' makes us sick

Taiwan's bid for full WHO membership was thwarted on Monday after the World Health Assembly (WHA) adopted a motion by a vote of 148 to 17 to exclude the issue from its agenda.

China was quick to hail the decision as a political victory backing its claims to Taiwan. Beijing's attitude made it amply clear that China viewed the issue as political from the start and that it was not concerned about the health rights of Taiwanese.

However, those who voted against Taiwan's bid for full membership in the WHO cannot simply wash their hands and walk away. They are equally guilty of turning a blind eye to the rights of 23 million people and for leaving a missing link in the global health framework by yielding to political pressure and excluding Taiwan.

The organization as a whole and its individual member states seem unbothered by the contradiction between a body's mandate to prioritize global health issues -- above political agendas -- and blocking an entire nation from that body.

China and its supporters argue that Taiwan is not left out of the network because China has signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the WHO, magnanimously promising to look after Taiwanese.

Forget politics. The reality of Taiwan's health system is that it is completely and utterly independent of China. The French might as well promise to protect the health of Germans.

Chinese Health Minister Gao Qiang claimed that the MOU -- which China signed with the WHO to shore up the "one China" principle in a body that is supposed to be apolitical -- has enabled Taiwan to send 23 experts to various technical conferences organized by the WHO.

What many do not know or choose to ignore is that the MOU restricts Taiwan's right to attend WHO forums and workshops on the latest developments in the diagnosis and control of pandemics and other vital issues. It also restricts the status of officials Taiwan is allowed to send and grants China the authority to approve or reject Taiwan's applications to attend workshops.

China has repeatedly delayed its approval of Taiwan's applications, even when turned in needlessly early, so that the Taiwanese representatives would not receive the go-ahead in time to take part in these conferences.

The SARS outbreak in 2003 claimed 73 lives in Taiwan, making it the country with the third-highest number of deaths after China and Hong Kong. Taiwan was forced to cope with SARS alone for about two months before the WHO sent two health experts to help deal with the crisis. Bizarrely, the WHO had to wait for the go-ahead from Beijing officials that have no control over Taiwan's health system and other agencies that were involved in containing the SARS virus.

How long will the WHO and its member states allow Taiwan to remain in this untenable position? One way or another, Taiwan is better off without China's magnanimity.

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

Politics supersede health!

San Antonio Express-News

Perhaps the World Health Organization, better known by the acronym WHO, should consider a new moniker. WHO-T would be more accurate. That's the World Health Organization, minus Taiwan.

WHO is the United Nations agency dedicated to health issues. Its objective is the attainment "by all peoples of the highest possible level of health."
Well, not exactly all peoples. The citizens of 193 member states are represented at WHO and its governing body, the World Health Assembly. Among them are the people of Niue, a South Pacific island with a population of 1,492.

Even the Holy See and the Palestine Liberation Organization have observer status.
But the 23 million residents of Taiwan are denied representation. As part of its "One-China" policy to diplomatically isolate Taiwan, China has blocked Taiwanese membership in WHO since 1972.

Beijing was even successful in denying accreditation to Taiwanese journalists attempting to cover the annual assembly taking place this week in Geneva. So it came as no surprise that Taiwan's annual bid for observer status in the international organization turned out no differently in 2007 than in years past.

That's an indictment of the U.N. institution, which ought to be able to separate issues of health and politics. More significant, it's an indictment of China's leaders who, despite controlling an economic and military behemoth, are political pygmies who despair of their democratic relatives on Taiwan.

Australia: Viruses wtihout Borders

China has blocked Taiwan's membership in the World Health Organization for the past quarter-century. The Beijing government's intransigence is inhumane and dangerous. A viral epidemic killed scores of Taiwanese children in 1998, but doctors on the island of 23 million people were denied the organization's resources.

Five years later, China allowed WHO experts on Taiwan only after more than a hundred people there were diagnosed with severe acute respiratory syndrome, or SARS - which had spread there from the mainland.Disease does not respect borders. Yet WHO teams are barred from Taiwan without China's approval because the United Nations, under pressure from Beijing, doesn't recognize Taiwan as a nation. The communist government of the People's Republic of China on the mainland regards the democratic, self-ruled island as a province. China fears Taiwan's participation in global organizations would imply sovereignty.

Today, the World Health Assembly will decide on Taiwan's application for membership - but the outcome seems foregone. That's a shame. The assembly should stand up to China.International trade and travel put Taiwan at risk of diseases such as bird flu, which scientists say could one day double world mortality. Taiwan rightly worries that without WHO membership, it could be cut off from information and aid in a pandemic. To deny the nation such an important affiliation isn't just cruel; it could endanger the health of the world.

Copyright 2007, Hartford Courant

The Beginning of a new diplomatic war front

The new drive launched by President Chen Shui-bian and the Democratic Progressive Party government to apply directly for membership in the World Health Organization in Geneva under the name of "Taiwan" has succeeded in pulling the authoritarian People's Republic of China into open and direct competition with "democratic Taiwan" in the arena of public diplomacy.

Taiwan is already an important contributor of medical and public health to lesser developed countries in Africa, Central and South America and the South Pacific, but despite these efforts and the danger to all of a "break in the chain" of global disease prevention, Taiwan is excluded from the WHO network.

After a decade of unsuccessful attempts to secure observer status at the World Health Assembly and thereby indirectly participate in WHO activities under the "non-political" umbrella of a "health entity," the DPP government and health activists issued a direct application to become a WHO member state in an official missive sent in early April to WHO Secretary-General Margaret Chan of Hong Kong.

The drive was backed by a publicity offensive that carried the message "Give Taiwan a seat in the WHO" as well as a transcontinental audiovisual press conference convened by Chen Friday with reporters in Taipei and Geneva.

The new gambit has sparked concern that a direct application could alienate the U.S., Japan and members of the EU who supported moves for "significant participation" given the specter of alleged "agenda" of the Taiwan president of promoting "legal independence."

However, in addition to opinion polls showing 95 percent support for Taiwan to enter the WHO, it is especially noteworthy that the Legislative Yuan unanimously approved a resolution Friday morning to "fully support the government's struggle to become a WHO member and uphold the basic health rights of Taiwan's 23 million people."

In light of the bitter divisions regarding national identity and virtually every other issue in the Legislature, the ability of the Kuomintang and its allied People First Party to back this resolution indicates that opposition parties don't see the WHO membership attempt as an "agenda" or "credibility" issue of Chen or the DPP but rather as a near unanimous consensus and joint demand by all our people.

As President Chen noted last Friday, the fact of the matter is that the PRC remains absolutely opposed to any indirect or direct, unofficial or official involvement by Taiwan in the WHO or any other international organizations, regardless of whether we use the "Republic of China" moniker or the "most beautiful and forceful" name of "Taiwan."

No more secret betrayals

This fact is demonstrated most clearly in the heretofore secret "Memorandum of Understanding Between the WHO Secretariat and China" signed on May 14, 2005, the third article of which explicitly refers to the "obligation of the Secretariat to refrain from actions which could constitute recognition of a separate status of Taiwanese authorities and institutions."

The MOU requires vetting by the PRC Ministry of Health for any contacts between the WHO and Taiwan, including the dispatch of WHO experts to what it insultingly refers to as "Taiwan, China" for "acute public health emergencies."

However, the signing of this secret pact constitutes a direct betrayal by the WHO Secretariat of its ideals of "Health for All" and a gross violation of the WHO Constitution, which does not grant the secretariat or the WHO director-general the right to decide whether a country or representative organization (such as the Palestine Liberation Organization, which is a WHO observer despite not being a U.N. member) should enjoy membership.

Indeed, by refusing Taiwan's entry into the WHO and acquiescing to this secret betrayal, the WHO Secretariat and all of the 192 WHO members are putting the rest of the world, including their own citizens, at risk purely for the sake of their desire to curry favor with the Beijing authorities or out of craven cowardice to challenge the PRC myth that it "owns" sovereignty over Taiwan.

The strategic points behind an application for membership is to force the WHO Secretariat and the World Health Assembly, under the WHO Constitution and the WHA by-laws, to respond directly to the issue and turn the matter to discussion by all member states and to expose the secret diplomacy of the WHO Secretariat and the authoritarian government to sell out not only the health rights of our people but also endanger the health rights of the rest of global society for the sake of Beijing's revanchism.

Naturally, the prospects for Taiwan's affiliation to the WHA or WHO will not immediately improve due to this gambit, but they can hardly be worsened since the main obstacle is the PRC itself.

A hint of what may come is shown by the sharp reaction by journalist rights groups, including the International Federation of Journalists and the Paris-based Reporters without Borders, to the decisions since 2004 by the U.N. office in Geneva, undoubtedly acting under Beijing's marching orders, to prohibit direct news coverage of the WHA meeting by Taiwan journalists simply because they are from Taiwan.

In a May 14th statement, Reporters without Borders condemned the "appalling discrimination" caused by the refusal by the U.N. and the WHO to accept accreditation requests from five Taiwan journalists to cover the WHA simply because they are from Taiwan and declared that the people of Taiwan "can fall victim to pandemics and have the right to be informed like anyone else."

Besides "pandering to Beijing's hostility to any Taiwanese presence within international bodies," RWB warned that the U.N. action "gives priority to the national issue rather than to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 19 of which guarantees press freedom and free circulation of information."

Despite yesterday's failure to win a place on the WHA agenda, we believe that the new strategy will ultimately be more effective at winning sympathy in world civil society and in turn promote broader support in the WHO itself.

Sunday, May 13, 2007

Expert: WHO entry is a moral, not political question

By Mei-chin Van Der Wees

Taiwan is a thriving democracy, has a vibrant economy and offers its citizens universal health care. The nation sends young medical doctors to African nations such as Burkina Faso and Malawi to improve health standards. It even offers to send peacekeepers to the world's hot spots, if allowed.

In other words, Taiwan is eager to be an active member of the international community, yet it has been locked out of nearly all global organizations.

WHO Director-General Margaret Chan (陳馮富珍) chose not to accept Taiwan's application for membership in the organization, saying that the reason for exclusion was that Taiwan "is not an independent state."

The nation is growing tired of such lame excuses, because, as almost everyone is aware, China is the real culprit behind Taiwan's international isolation.

To exclude the 23 million Taiwanese from the WHO, to deprive them of the universal rights to the prevention of and treatment of infectious disease in a global outbreak is simply morally wrong.

In 2003, when Taiwan was hit by SARS, the WHO initially refused to offer medical aid and vaccines to Taiwan. Taiwanese health authorities had to go to the Internet to search for information about SARS and more than 35 Taiwanese perished because of delays in treatment.

In effect, excluding Taiwan from the WHO will leave a hole in the global epidemic prevention network because bacteria and viruses know no boundaries.

It is not up to Chan to decide whether Taiwan is a nation or not: Under the criteria established in the 1933 Montevideo Convention, Taiwan is a sovereign state with effective control of a territory.

To sidestep the issue of sovereignty, Taiwan applied to become an observer at World Health Assembly as a health "entity" in 1997. For 10 consecutive years, however, because of opposition from China, its application has never even been put on the health assembly's agenda.

This year, the government decided to apply for entry to the WHO as a full member under the name Taiwan. WHO rules and regulations state that membership applications should be put on the agency's agenda and brought to the attention of member states. None of these steps were taken and the application was rejected before it ever had a chance.

To the great disappointment of the Taiwanese, the US government has refused to support Taiwan's full membership in the WHO, lamely citing its "one China" policy.

But let us go back to the basic principle of the WHO, which is "health for all." If a doctor refuses to treat a patient because of his or her political views, he or she will be censored by the medical board. By the same token it is unconscionable for the WHO and its member states to exclude Taiwan.

The universal right of the 23 million Taiwanese to the prevention and treatment of infectious disease is not and should not be a political issue, but a human rights and moral issue. Simply put, it is morally wrong to treat Taiwanese like second-class citizens.


Mei-chin van der Wees is a writer based in Washington

Wednesday, May 9, 2007

WHO, the World “Hypocrite” Organization?

As the premier international health watchdog, the World Health Organization aims to protect the health of all people regardless of region, color, race, age, or gender. The statement sounds perfectly humanitarian and even worthy of praise.

However, while it is true that the WHO has done much good and deserves to be applauded for its efforts in eradicating many diseases from the world, it is also true that the WHO is systematically putting people in harm’s way.

Such as in the case of Taiwan, an island country of 23 million that has been completely alienated from the health body for the last 50 years.

What has Taiwan done to be shut out by the WHO? Has Taiwan violated any international health code or committed a despicable crime to deserve such alienation?

The answer is yes: by becoming one of the most successful emerging democracies that promotes the freedom of press, speech, media, and religion on the island and in the world. In the eyes of WHO and its mother organization the United Nations, defending Taiwan’s democracy is far less important than catering to the interests of communist China.

The irony is astounding. Taiwan’s hard won democracy is the very reason why it is not embraced by a democratically organized group. Democracy is the only obstacle preventing Taiwan from winning supports from other democratic nations.

Sadly, the day that Taiwan waves its white flag to Communist China, is the day it will receive the protection it deserves from the WHO, the UN, and many other international organizations that subordinate themselves to the so-called “One-China” policy.

The paradox of the situation is a direct mockery to principle of democracy. Why should a group of democratically-minded people be coerced into communism in order to be protected from harmful contagions? It really makes one wonder does the “H” in WHO really means “health” or rather… “hypocrite”?

By using the “One-China Policy” as a justification to refuse Taiwan’s application to become part of the WHO, the majority of the WHO member-states are simply demanding the Taiwanese citizens to give up their freedom in exchange of health security.

The last time I checked, health security is one of the most basic human rights, not an elite privilege reserved for members of an esoteric fraternity.

Part of the Hippocratic Oath for medical doctors is to “never to do deliberate harm to anyone for anyone else’s interest.” A violation of this vow can, and often does, result in the suspension of a medical practitioner's license to practice.

If this oath applies to the WHO-and it should- then the WHO Director-General Margaret Chan should be immediately banned from all hospitals and clinics. Health ministers from over 165 countries should also be chastised for serving the political interests of China by ignoring Taiwan’s rights to health.

The WHO should revised its constitution and state that the organization protects the health rights of all people, except if you are a freedom loving individual who happens to hold a passport with the word “Taiwan” written on its green cover.

That way, the WHO will at least be telling the truth, however ugly and discriminatory it may be.


Jenny Hsu
Taipei, Taiwan

Tuesday, May 8, 2007

Excluding Taiwan from WHO is a prescription for disaster - World Health Organization

The World Health Organization's (WHO's) stated purpose is to facilitate "the attainment by all people of the highest possible level of health." Its membership includes more than 190 nations. Some you'd need a magnifying glass to find on a globe. Others are countries whose governments constitute the primary threat to the health of their people--among them Cuba, North Korea, Iran, Syria, Sudan and Iraq.

A number of nonstate entities have observer status, such as the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and International Red Cross. Conspicuous by its absence is Taiwan, with a population larger than 75 percent of WHO members. Thus, the island's 23 million people currently are excluded from WHO's touted objective of helping "all people" to attain "the highest possible level of health."

When it meets in Geneva in mid-May, WHO's governing body will have an opportunity to rectify this injustice. For the seventh time, Taiwan will apply for observer status. Other international bodies have made an effort to accommodate the island. It's currently a member of the World Trade Organization as a "customs territory" and the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation group as an "economic entity."
But once again Taiwan's bid for recognition by WHO will meet with formidable opposition from the People's Republic of China. In the international arena, Beijing wishes Taiwan to be invisible. It opposes any participation for the island in WHO as a member or even as an observer.

More than petulant, this is downright dangerous. In an age of globalization characterized by the increasing flow of people and goods internationally, excluding 23 million people from WHO--especially those whose island is situated at the hub of Asia's trade--is perilous.

At its 107th session in January 2001, WHO's executive board cautioned: "The globalization of infectious diseases is such that an outbreak in one country is potentially a threat to the whole world. The need for international cooperation on epidemic alert and response is greater today than ever before due to increased population movements, growth in international trade and biological products, changes in methods of food processing [and] social and environmental changes."
When it comes to Taiwan, the WHO simply ignores this threat. Taiwan already has reported several cases of SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome), the new and highly contagious form of pneumonia that originated in China. Exclusion from WHO means Taiwan can't participate in the organization's Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network, which monitors disease trends and shares health data among its partners.

Taiwan also had to go it alone in 1998 when the enterovirus epidemic swept the island, killing 80 and hospitalizing more than 400.
When an earthquake measuring 7.6 on the Richter scale hit Taiwan in 1999, killing more than 2,400 and leaving 100,000 homeless, WHO wasted precious time trying to devise "unofficial" ways to provide "indirect" medical assistance to survivors. By contrast, its response to the 1997 avian-flu epidemic in Hong Kong was swift and sure.

From the perspective of global-health concerns, it makes sense for Taiwan to be part of WHO. Millions visit the island each year and millions of Taiwanese travel abroad. There's a constant flow of health-risk-related products entering and leaving the island annually, including $2 billion in animals and animal products, $2.3 billion in vegetable products and $2.5 billion in prepared foodstuffs.
Taiwan could make a considerable contribution to WHO's global efforts. It has abundant health resources that it is eager to share with the world. Taiwan has eliminated most infectious diseases (including smallpox, rabies and malaria). It boasts one of the highest levels of life expectancy in Asia. Its healthcare system is rated among the best in the developed world.

Each year Taiwan bestows more than $120 million in medical aid and humanitarian relief on 78 countries. It currently has medical teams hard at work in Malawi, Chad, Burkina Faso and a number of other nations.
Keeping Taiwan's 23 million educated and energetic people outside the WHO is a waste of human resources and a danger to both the Taiwanese and the international community. This is a fact recognized by the World Medical Association, the Japanese government, the European Union's commissioner for external relations and the U.S. House of Representatives (by resolution adopted March 11). All have urged WHO to grant observer status to Taiwan.

It remains to be seen whether health considerations and common sense overcome the latest aspect of China's international vendetta against Taiwan.

DON FEDER IS A TALK-SHOW HOST ON WROL-AM 950 IN BOSTON.

"One China" at the WHO?

President Chen Shui-bian recently sent a WHO membership application letter directly to WHO Director-General Margaret Chan. Shortly afterwards, Chan said in an interview with CNN that the "one China" policy was the principle guiding the WHO and that she would use this principle as a guiding light on issues regarding Taiwan.

Some pundits have argued that Chan's position would put Taiwan into a more difficult situation. The Foundation of Medical Professionals Alliance in Taiwan, which has dedicated itself for a long time to to promoting "Taiwan for the WHO," would like to shed some light on the situation.

It is important first to distinguish between observer status and full membership. There is no such a thing as observer status in the WHO Constitution. Reference to this status, however, is made in the body's Rules of Procedure. The concept of observer status has therefore emerged through practice.

Observers can only take part in the one-week World Health Assembly (WHA) held annually in May, where WHO members meet to discuss and share information on epidemics. Only mini-states, such as the Holy See, and non-governmental organizations such as the International Committee of the Red Cross, have observer status at the WHA.

Observer status is deliberated upon and ultimately granted by the WHA.

But should the WHO abide by the "one China" principle? In April 2004, the WHO's former director-general, Lee Jong-wook of South Korea, made a comment similar comment to Chang's, but WHO spokesman Iain Simpson said that Lee's remark had been misquoted and there was no such a thing as a "one China" principle at the WHO.

Applications for membership, he said, should therefore be determined by member states, while the WHO secretariat had no authority on this issue.

Since there is no provision in the WHO Constitution and the WHA Rules of Procedure specifying the director-general's right to decide whether certain entities are states or not, and given the political sensitivity of the issue, WHO chiefs have turned to various avoidance techniques.

East Germany's application in 1968 provides an illuminating example. At the time, West Germany was already a WHO member and complied with the "one Germany" policy, known as the Hallstein Doctrine. The WHO director-general at the time took two separate actions after receiving the East's application: He first circulated the application and placed it on the WHA agenda, making a formal reference to the Rules of Procedure. To avoid having to make a decision on his own, he then sent a letter to WHO members in which he argued that East Germany's application would need to be debated at the WHA.

In 1972, the director-general used Rule 3 of the Rules of Procedure, which states that "the director-general may invite states having made application for membership to send observers to sessions of the health assembly."

That year, East Germany sent observers to attend the WHA meeting and became a WHO member the next year.

Given this precedent, Chang's statements undoubtedly went beyond a director-general's remit. As such, we call on the director-general to abide by the established procedures rather than make her own political preferences policy.

Twice in the past -- in 1997 and 2004 -- Taiwan applied for observer status at the WHA, but the content of the application was in fact "whether to place Taiwan's application for WHA observership on the agenda of the assembly." This was therefore merely a matter of procedure rather than a vote on a substantive issue.

This year, however, Chen used Rule 3 of the Rules of Procedure to apply for membership, which should have resulted in an invitation by the WHO director-general to participate as an observer. This strategy was meant to prevent procedure from being used to block Taiwan's application and dovetailed with US and Japanese support for Taiwan to obtain observer status at the WHA.

Since its very beginning, the WHO has stressed the universality of membership. Applicants can become full members with the approval of half of member states, without any possibility of a veto.

During the early 1950s, West Germany and Japan were still under occupation, meaning that their external relations were being handled by the occupying powers. Nevertheless, they both became members of the WHO.

For the WHO to spend large amounts of resources and budgets trying to build a seamless global epidemic prevention network while excluding Taiwan is as unconscionable as it is illogical.

Lin Shih-chia

Executive director, Foundation of Medical Professionals Alliance in Taiwan

Please Give Us Formal Status, Otherwise It's Meaningless!

A friend of mine forwarded the following letter to me. I thought it's worth reading.


Dr. T
===========================================================

A letter to European Union concerning WHO---From the private sector in Taiwan

Please Give Us Formal Status, Otherwise It’s Meaningless

We sincerely appreciate European Union’s support for Taiwan’s “meaningful participation” in the WHO since last year. However, after our striving for participation we found that only when EU government assists Taiwan to acquire formal status---WHO membership can we be really helped.

1. “Meaningful participation” is limited!

The Foundation of Medical Professionals Alliance in Taiwan has visited the representatives of EU countries in Taiwan early this month, all the representatives said they supported Taiwan’s meaningful participation, but when talking about the status to participate in the WHO, they all told us it’s impossible for them to support Taiwan to be the observer or member of WHO. At the same time Taiwan has only participated in 19 WHO related meetings from June 2005 to December 2006, not to mention our name was changed in some of the meetings. Everyone claimed that Taiwan has participated in 40% of the WHO expert meetings, thus we can roughly make the number of WHO meetings per year as 37. The Foundation of Medical Professionals Alliance in Taiwan has held 3 international conferences within last year, and then we could imagine how many meetings has been held by WHO. Everyone who was medically trained knows that a patient who feels like vomiting could have glaucoma instead of digestive disease; it’s the same that we need complete medical and health information instead of fragmented “meaningful” information.

2.As an international organization, the WHO secretariat should not sign MOU with particular member---China without informing other member states and stipulate that every conference information given to Taiwan should go through Beijing government first.

Mr. BURCI, the Legal Counsel of WHO once said privately that the WHO related meetings contain various fields that we are not able to confirm how many meetings have been held WHO! Thus we have no idea that Taiwan has been excluded from how many “meaningful” meetings. Accordingly, it is meaningless to talk about the number of meetings in which Taiwan has participated. The WHO Secretariat signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with China which requires WHO authorities to “consult with the Chinese government” before offering any information to Taiwan or inviting Taiwan to the meetings.Transparency is the most important for an international organization. The secretariat of WHO should not sign the MOU with particular members separately. The content of the MOU could damage the rights of other member states. What’s more ridiculous is that China is the country aiming 800 missiles at Taiwan! The WHO secretariat has made a serious mistake to let China decide which meetings are meaningful for Taiwan! Please urge the WHO to reveal the details of the MOU publicly to protect the rights of every member state and facilitate EU countries’ support to Taiwan’s meaningful participation in the WHO.

3. Untransparent epidemic situation in China is threatening the world, and Taiwan is the first to be affected!

China was hiding the epidemic situation during SARS attack, which led to the SARS outbreak in Taiwan, the people of Taiwan had suffered the trauma mentally and physically at that time, this has been well known by the world. Beijing is currently having the rabies outbreak, there had been 1,735 people reportedly died of rabies during January to August 2006. The Beijing government was forced to set the “one dog” policy for every household. Taiwan, as an island country and China’s close neighbour, has completely eradicated rabies since 1959; however, the animal smuggling and untransparent epidemic situation in China have put Taiwan under tremendous threat. For the people of Taiwan, the biggest insecurity comes from China! All the WHO related information given to Taiwan have to go through the country which is lagging behind on health and hostile to Taiwan---China first. All the people of Taiwan are terrified by the disease coming from China including avian flu.

Again we appreciate European Union’s support for Taiwan, but the statement above has proved that the so called “Taiwan’s meaningful participation in the WHO” is hard to be executed through current approach, including letting China decide which information and meetings are meaningful for Taiwan on the basis of the MOU signed between China and the WHO secretariat.

For Taiwan, only when we gain the formal status of WHO can we get the overall health information. Therefore, we appeal to EU for changing their policy and “supporting Taiwan to be the member of WHO”!

Dr. Shuh-Min WuPresident, Foundation of Medical Professionals Alliance in Taiwan

A letter from a French professor

This year, the government of Taiwan decides to officially demand the World Health Organization the status of full membership for the people of Taiwan. This new initiative was announced by the secretary general of the office of the President, the minister of foreign affairs and the minister of Health in a press conference held on 12 April 2007. This announcement changed the strategy which has been adopted by the Taiwanese Authority in the past ten years, advocating for the country to be an observer in the World Health Assembly.

In the past decades, the WHO administration has been under constant pressure from China and kept ignoring the repeated request of granting Taiwan the status of the membership. During the outbreak of SARS, Taiwan was in constant danger of the virus threat from China, the officials of the WHO just simply refused to help Taiwan because of one political reason: Taiwan is not member of WHO. Fortunately, with the assistance of specialists from the US and Japan, the SARS epidemic was under controlled over a short period of time.

The majority of the people who work for the World Health Organization have a medical background. As we know, the duty of a doctor is to save people in danger despite race, gender, or political affiliation. But specialists from WHO refused to save people in Taiwan for the reason that China has been long against the idea. In fact, it is the WHO that failed to fulfill the principals of its funding motto.

In fact, it is written in the Constitution of WHO that the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being without distinction of race, religion, political belief, economic or social condition. But the administrations of the WHO just completely ignored the Constitution and continue to discriminate Taiwan.

Moreover, the world is facing now a new danger in the spread of bird flu as many countries are facing perilous prospects in which humanity is severely threatened if it is not properly contained. The SARS epidemic was the most suitable moment for WHO to accept Taiwan, but nothing happened. To protect the people in Taiwan as well as the whole world, the new policy of the government of Taiwan is to urge the administration of WHO to acknowledge the danger caused by the epidemic and take necessary precaution against it. If the administrations of WHO continue to take the stand of discrimination against Taiwan, they might have to accept the dire and unimaginable consequences.

Tuesday, May 1, 2007

Should the WHO hold “One-China Policy”?

Just weeks ago, President Chen Shui-Bien of Taiwan has written a letter directly addressed to WHO Director-General Margret Chan, stating Taiwan’s intention to apply for full membership of the organisation. The Director-General then went on to CNN responding that since “one-China policy” is THE overriding principal of the organisation, as the first ranking official she will deal with the issue regarding Taiwan according to this presiding policy. Some media outlets subsequently pointed out that the assertion by the Director-General would exacerbate the predicament Taiwan is facing at the moment. Due to the fact that Foundation of Medical Professional Alliance in Taiwan (FMPAT) has long been actively involved in the bid for WHO membership, I would like to provide some humble opinions regarding the subject.

First of all, we have to distinguish the difference between “observeship” and “membership”. According to the WHO constitution, the term “observship” does not exist in the apparatus of the organisation, the so-called “observeship” is a status granted to microscopic nations like the Vatican or international NGOs such as the Red Cross that allows them to attend the WHO assembly for the week in May every year in which all the membership countries are present, yet with very limited participation.

If we return to our argument, does or should the WHO hold the so-called “One-China policy”? In April 2004, the former Director-General Lee Jong Wook of South Korea has brought up the issue in his speech but then was later clarified by the organisation’s spokesman as being “misquoted”, stressing that WHO does not have “One-China policy” and all applications should be reviewed by the membership countries as the WHO secretariat has no authority over this. Due to the fact that the rules of procedure in either the WHO or WHA have not explicitly explained the Director-General’s authority on the verification of statehood, along with the political sensitivity surrounding the issue, the former Director-Generals have nonetheless kept well away on the ground of technicality, refraining themselves from the tricky role of an arbitrator on the qualification of the applicants.

Take East Germany for example; in 1968 when West Germany was already a member of WHO, the Director-General did two things after the organisation received the application of East Germany. First of all, he filed a motion which put the case on the agenda of the assembly along with the related constitution and rules of procedure for all the members to consult. Moreover, in order to eliminate the possibility of a preconceived agenda, he wrote an open letter stating that it should be up to the assembly to decide on East Germany’s application, not him. In 1972, the Director-General quoted article III of WHA constitution, “the Director-General can invite the applicant countries… to attend the WHA assembly as observant”, in that very year, East Germany obtained observship and attended the assembly, and was granted membership the following year.

Hence, the assertion made by Margret Chen has overstepped the boundaries and indeed broken the tradition regarding the authority of the Director-General. We would like to call on the Director-General to follow the adequate procedure instead of acting on one’s own judgement.

Since the establishment of WHO, it has in many occasions stressed the universality of its membership; therefore it only requires consents from half of the membership countries, and what is more important is that there is no veto right. After WWII, when East Germany and Japan were both still under allies occupation, they have already obtained membership status despite the fact that they were not even in theUN. For this reason, why the WHO on the one hand, put up a massive budget in constructing the invincible global health defence system and on the other, trying every mean to prevent Taiwan from joining the organisation?

Tuesday, April 24, 2007

Problems Taiwan faced in the bid for WHO membership

Every year as May approaches, comes the season for the government of Taiwan to launch vigorously its bid to join the World Health Organization (WHO). To be a part of this organisation is not only one of the major diplomatic efforts by the current DPP government; it is also the expectation of the general public in Taiwan.
Since the establishment of the organisation in 1948, the WHO has dedicated itself to pursue the highest health standard for universal human beings, and ultimately set up its funding principal by maintaining it. Through providing health and medical consultation and technical help as well as promoting public awareness regarding all kinds of diseases and general knowledge of hygiene, it has assisted countries throughout the world on elevating the health standard of people. Due to the fact that Taiwan is not a member of the organisation, all levels of access to the international community are blocked whether official or unofficial. Not only has it been impossible for Taiwan’s government officials to join meetings or discussions regarding global health policies, it is frustrating to see that even civil participation in conventions hosted or sponsored by the WHO has met with strong resistance. As a result of this, the island has been denied as a part of the WHO global heath immune system, and without the access to obtain constant information and related techniques, a terrifying hole was created in the global effort to counter bioterrorism and prevent the spread of infectious diseases.
In these couple of decades, the tremendous achievement of heath system in Taiwan can easily be witnessed, the government has been actively participating in all kinds of international movements regarding the matter, yet it has been regrettable that since Taiwan does not enjoy the full membership of the WHO, the impact of the Taiwanese society is limited as it has tried hard to extend its arms to every corner of the world. In 1997, in order to safeguarding the welfare of some 23 million strong population, and also to fulfil its obligation as a member of the international community, the government of Taiwan has petitioned for the membership of the WHO. Unfortunately, in the past ten years, China has used every means possible to prevent Taiwan from reaching this goal. In spite of this, the efforts did not just stop there, as Taiwan continued to further this cause through allies in the WHO to file motion that allows Taiwan to speak directly to the assembly, elaborating the concepts and ideals behind this relentless pursuit to the international community. It seemed that along with all the hard works by Taiwan’s government and the tireless lobbying by elected legislators and civic organisations, most WHO membership countries have taken a more positive and understanding stance towards Taiwan’s endeavour.
However, the biggest problem in joining the WHO is the blurred status regarding the national identity of Taiwan. As far as Palestine is concerned, despite the long history of conflict with Israel, its status as a sovereign nation was never questioned. If we look at the case of Taiwan, it is a self-proclaimed “public heath entity,” yet only request to be put on the WHO membership observant list. Such act has caused great damage to the sovereignty of Taiwan, and from the international legal perspective, it does no help in elevating the status of Taiwan internationally, or contributing to the understanding that Taiwan and China are two totally separate political entities. It takes more than the status of an observant to do so.
Therefore, if Taiwan regards itself as an autonomous country, it needs to directly apply for full membership in the WHO, but if this is not the case, then the government should honestly point out the direction to the public as to where do we go from here. We cannot allow the confusion of the realization that Taiwan is independent on the one hand, and then being subjected to the disguise of “one China policy” on the other. The government has to be clear on this.