Showing posts with label APEC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label APEC. Show all posts

Friday, September 14, 2007

Assessing the Development of Asia-Pacific Trade and Economic Institutions through the Lens of Geo-Political Economy (PART II)

Regional development in Asia is characterized by the struggles between the principles of “Asia-Pacificism” and “Asianism.” To maximize benefits, countries in the Asia Pacific region must engage in both multilateral cooperation and bilateral FTA agreements, aiming to find a balance between these two principles.

It was not the first time when Mahathir openly advocated alternative institutions. In 1990, he espoused the idea of an East Asian Economic Group (EAEG), which consisted of ASEAN members, Japan, China and South Korea. Facing opposition from the US and other developed country members, the proposition did not lead to a separate regional organization, but was instead incorporated into the APEC framework and renamed East Asia Economic Caucus (EAEC). But Mahathir did not give up. When Malaysia was the chair of the 30th anniversary ASEAN meeting, Mahathir used this opportunity to personally invite leaders from Japan, China and South Korea to attend the meeting. Since then, alternative cooperative mechanisms such as ASEAN+3 (ASEAN plus Japan, China and South Korea) and ASEAN+1 (ASEAN plus Japan and China) flourished. Starting from 2000, various ministerial-level meeting have taken place. These meetings not only became annual forums for policy discussion and consensus but also led to significant progress. Take year 2005 as example. The Chiang-Mai Initiative, which creates a network of bilateral currency swap among ASEAN+3 countries to address short-term liquidity difficulty within region, was formulated during ASEAN+3 financial ministerial meeting that year. At the same time, different versions of Asian-centered “Free Trade Agreement” (FTA) were proposed. It was also a year when ASEAN+3 meetings were elevated to bi-annual East Asia Summit.

ASEAN’s regional initiatives resulted in various forms and levels of regional cooperation. After Japan’s proposal, in 1999 leaders from Japan, China and South Korea met for a caucus. This meeting established precedent for future annual meetings between the three and thus was a starting point for Northeast Asian cooperation. In addition to this landmark event, bilateral and multilateral FTAs between Japan, China and South Korea were also proposed and under progress.

This trend of Asian-centered regional cooperation does not spell the waning influence of the “Asia-Pacific” centered APEC. During the 2004 APEC meeting in Peru, the presence of Sino-US trade conflicts did not preclude members from declaring their support over trade and financial liberalization, the resumption of Doha Round, free trade agreements, anti-terrorism and anti-corruption efforts. In response to rising trade volume and export competitiveness in East Asia, participants of the 11th APEC Trade Minister’s meeting issued the Jeju Declaration. According to the Jeju Declaration, members would adopt the Swiss Formula, which allows higher tariff reduction for non-agricultural goods (NAMA) with high initial tariffs. As shown by recent APEC and WTO meetings, market opening and agriculture issues continue to be significant yet sensitive. This means that, even though member countries’ individual interests prevent the APEC from becoming a more institutionalized organization, it is still a major communication and cooperation channel for developed and developing countries in the region.

Regional development in Asia is characterized by the struggles between the principles of Asia-Pacificism and Asianism. Under the strong man leadership of the US, the former principle led to the creation of APEC, a loosely structured organization made of both developed and developing countries. Stressing the so-called “Asian characteristics,” the latter principle and its advocates face suspicion and even opposition from supporters of Asia-Pacificism. To maximize their benefits, then, countries in the Asia Pacific must engage in both multilateral cooperation and bilateral FTA agreements, aiming to find a balance between these two principles.

2007 APEC Summit and Current Asia Pacific—Create an Asia-Pacific Democracy Partnership?

Under the theme of “Strengthening Our Community, Building a Sustainable Future,” the 2007 APEC Leaders’ Summit was held in Sydney on September 8-9, 2007. The main issues of this year’s meeting arranged by Australia were climate change, WTO Doha Round negotiation, regional economic integration, human security, and APEC reform.

In addition to the usual APEC Ministerial Joint Statement and Leaders’ Declaration, the Leaders’ Summit this year had also produced an individual declaration for climate change, energy security and clean development, called “Sydney Declaration.” To push forward the WTO Doha Round negotiation, APEC leaders this year again issued a stand-alone statement.

From the standpoint of APEC multilateral meeting, this year’s APEC Leaders’ Summit was unique in that they discussed climate change first and then economy and trade. With the rising importance of issues regarding abnormal climate and greenhouse gas emissions, APEC Leaders, for the first time, stated their views in the Declaration on Climate Change, Energy Security and Clean Development. They also declared their support for the United Nation Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the development of an arrangement for the post-Kyoto Protocol (post-2012) era.

With regard to economic and trade issues, APEC had been calling for the successful conclusion of the Doha Round talk, and had developed a specific Declaration regarding this issue. Additionally, APEC Leaders had endorsed the Regional Economic Integration Report from the Ministerial Meeting. Regional economic integration was mentioned in the Leaders’ Declaration together with the topic of Free Trade Area of the Asia-Pacific (FTAAP). Leaders called for examining the options and prospects for a possible FTAAP via a range of practical and incremental steps.

On the subject of strengthening human security, APEC Leaders believed that terrorism, natural disasters, contaminated products, contagious diseases, energy security could continue to affect economic growth and standard of living in APEC. As for the APEC reform, it was agreed that APEC membership fees would increase by 30% in 2009. The creation of the Policy Support Unit within the APEC Secretariat for providing expert analyses and research was passed as well. Leaders also endorsed the idea of discussing about the need for an Executive Director of the APEC Secretariat with a fixed term.

The Sydney Leaders’ Summit not only occurred in a multilateral manner, but also consisted of bilateral talks. The bilateral talks of this year had focused on political security more than economic cooperation. The main outcomes of different bilateral talks consisted of U.S.-Australia anti-terrorism cooperation, and Australia's agreement to continue with troop deployment in Iraq. Australia and the U.S. also signed Defense Trade Cooperation Agreement, so that Australia could receive the latest weaponry and technology like the United Kingdom. As for China-Australia cooperation, China bought about US$45 billion of natural gas from Australia. Security dialogues between China and Australia would also start soon. China and the U.S. agreed to set up hot lines between the White House and Beijing. The U.S. also raised several concerns with China, such as product safety, trade imbalance, religious freedom, and the situation in Sudan. Besides, the U.S. expects that the Chinese government can express its commitment to openness and tolerance through hosting the 2008 Olympic Games. The U.S. briefly mentioned about the need for maintaining the status quo across the Taiwan Strait.

In order not to provoke China, the first trilateral security dialogue was held quietly among Leaders of Australia, Japan, and the U.S. The main topic of the dialogue was about India’s global strategic status, since India is the world’s largest democracy. Even though India had not been invited to the meeting, there was support for elevating India’s role in both regional and global seating. With this, a proposed Asia-Pacific democracy partnership seems about to occur.

More importantly, from the development of multilateral and bilateral meetings of the APEC Leaders’ Summit, the Asia-Pacific region indeed has not been static but dynamic. The region has been changing and the main points are as follows:

First, environmental politics and diplomacy have emerged in the Asia-Pacific region. Climate change is no longer just an environmental problem. Now with its extended impact on politics, economy and development, in the future, the issue of climate change will be not only related to energy development and economic competition, but also about allocation of global public resources. As such, the future trend in the Asia-Pacific region is that the subject of climate change will gain increasing importance.

Second, regional economic integration has become significant for APEC together with WTO multilateral trade liberalization. From the outset APEC has all the time given priority to the support for WTO multilateral trading system. However, with the rising significance of free trade agreements (FTAs) and regionalism, and the slowing of WTO negotiations, the idea of an Asia-Pacific free trade area has increasingly received greater attention from APEC members. Under the circumstances, there is the possibility that the significance of regional economic integration in the Asia-Pacific region will not be too far behind WTO multilateral trade liberalization.

Third, the gap between developing countries and developed countries is still wide. Many key players, such as the U.S., China, Japan, Australia and the ASEAN countries, will care more about their own interests and compete with each other for becoming the major architects for this region. The gap and conflicts have also become evident in the issues of climate change, regional economic integration, and APEC reform; one can observe the differences in positions between developing and developed countries.

Last but not the least, the U.S., Japan, Australia, and India are seeking to create an Asia-Pacific democracy partnership. U.S. President Bush had emphasized the importance of freedom in the Asia-Pacific region and the widening of democracy in this year’s APEC gathering. The meeting among U.S., Japan, and Australia had also mentioned the creation of the aforementioned partnership and had discussed the role of India. Japan has also openly stated that Japan and India have common interests, such as the support for democracy and freedom. In this sense, we can infer that a powerful and intangible partnership focusing on the promotion of democracy has begun to develop in the Asia-Pacific region.

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Assessing the Development of Asia-Pacific Trade and Economic Institutions through the Lens of Geo-Political Economy (PART I)

Regional development in Asia is characterized by the struggles between the principles of “Asia-Pacificism” and “Asianism.” To maximize benefits, countries in the Asia Pacific region must engage in both multilateral cooperation and bilateral FTA agreements, aiming to find a balance between these two principles.

The rise of sectoral division of labor and multinational trade in the Asia-Pacific region has greatly facilitated trade within East Asia. According to the WTO, Asia’s intraregional trade in 2003 reached 949 billion US dollars in total, while trade within North America only reached 404 billion US dollars. That is, trade within Asia is about 49.9% of total value of export, which is 9.4% more than those in North America.

The figures above indicate a trend of “trade integration” within Asia. During 2005 Boao Forum, Japan’s former Minister of Foreign Affairs Yoriko Kawaguchi noted that Northeast Asia’s intraregional trade increased from 34% in 1980 to 58% (of global trade) in 2003, while trade within North America FTA was only 55%. Despite such impressive number, the Asia-Pacific is marked by the presence of complicated and multi-faceted political-economic relations. As such, many countries in the Asia-Pacific are prevented from achieving greater economic cooperation.

Two regional doctrines—Asianism and Asia-Pacificism—have delayed the process of greater economic cooperation within the Asia Pacific region. The former, supported by the ASEAN members and China, views the region as “Asian Pacific,” one that includes members with similar cultural background—in other words, Asian countries. Meanwhile, the US and other industrialized countries advocate the geographically-based “Asia-Pacific,” one that considers countries in the Pacific—not just those in Asia—as part of the region.

The struggle between these two forces explains the shift from early effort on developing Asia Pacific Economic Co-operation (APEC), an organization that includes countries such as the US and Australia, to late 1990’s regional cooperation that centers on Asian countries. Since 1992, the US has invested tremendous amount of effort in developing the APEC. However, due to the existence of divergent perspectives among the developed and developing countries in the APEC, the efforts to balance them are often backfired, generating clashes throughout the Asia-Pacific’s path to open regionalism.

The three central pillars of the APEC are: trade and investment liberalization; business facilitation; economic and technical cooperation (Ecotech). To elicit developing countries’ cooperation, members from developed countries, which usually lean towards the first two pillars, declare their willingness to provide Ecotech to developing countries. Under the influence of the US, however, the APEC’s development still veers towards the first two pillars. It is no wonder that members from developing countries remain suspicious of the APEC.

Such underlying tension became apparent during the Asian Financial Crisis. As a loose institutional structure, the APEC failed to become a “hub” for member countries to address and manage the crisis. Even the major force behind the APEC, meaning the US, did not provide adequate and immediate assistance to crisis stricken countries. Such inadequate responses led to massive criticisms among Southeast Asian members, which prompted Malaysia’s former Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad to call for Asian nations’ withdrawal of APEC membership.

Monday, August 20, 2007

The Acer founder Stan Shih will represent Taiwan at the 2007 APEC forum

This year’s Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum will be held in Sydney on September 8 and 9. David Spencer, Australia’s Ambassador to APEC, presented Taiwan President Chen Shui-bian the written invitation from Australian Prime Minister John Howard that addressed Chen as “President Chen Shui-bian.” For the coming summit, Chen has appointed Acer Group Founder Stan Shih as his envoy.

President Chen considered Stan Shih as the best spokesman for Taiwan in the international community due to his contribution in putting Taiwan on the world’s high-tech map. Last year, Shih was named by Time magazine as one of the “60 Years of Asian Heroes” who have shaped the times over the last six decades in Asia. He was also given the title of “Star of Asia” in 2004 by Business Week.

President Chen told Spencer that as the founder of the Acer group, Stan Shih has boosted Taiwan’s image in the international arena as well. There is no doubt that global acceptance of the Acer brand has helped to associate “Made in Taiwan” products with high levels of quality.

The major goal of Taiwan’s delegate for this summit will be to inform the APEC member countries that Taiwan is able to make a solid contribution in efforts to control greenhouse gas emissions. In addition, Taiwan will put forth a proposal during the summit to make known Taiwan’s efforts to address global warning and climate change issues in five areas including environmental protection in industry, consumption patterns, clean production, pollution control, and greenhouse gas reduction.

(Excerpts from Taipei Times and Taiwan News)

Monday, August 6, 2007

Beijing May Boycott Taiwan's APEC Envoy; DPP initiates UN Bid Parade

It is speculated that Beijing may object to the presence of former vice premier Tsai Ying-wen as Taiwan's special envoy to the APEC leaders’ summit in Sydney next month.

Taiwan’s President Chen Shui-bian said, “China’s oppression has been constant. If [Beijing's opposition to Tsai's participation at the APEC summit] is true, it would demonstrate that China’s suppression of Taiwan has nothing to do with whether you are a man or a woman.”
Taiwanese presidents have been barred from attending APEC summits due to objections from the PRC. As a result, Taiwan’s president has to appoint a representative to attend the summits on his behalf.

Chen did not confirm whether he had appointed Tsai but stressed that Taiwan must not give up simply because of China’s oppression. He also urged Taiwan’s government to adhere to principles and strive for acceptance in the international community.

**********

Regarding the development of Taiwan’s bid to join the UN, the Democratic Progressive Party plans a series of activities to solicit support from around the world for the nation's bid to join the world body under the name “Taiwan,” including a massive parade in Kaohsiung on Sept. 15. On that day, the party hopes to attract 50,000 people to the parade in Kaohsiung.

The DPP Central Standing Committee also announced that it will seek 1.2 million endorsement signatures before Oct. 15 to underscore Taiwan’s determination to enter the UN as a full member.


(Excerpts from Taipei Times)